Best Bookkeeping Services near Brookhaven, NY

These companies serve Brookhaven from nearby bases in towns including Ronkonkoma, Nesconset and Patchogue.

15 companies listed · 3 open weekends · 13 rated 4.5+ · 1 shows a license

Data verified November 4, 2026

Castaldo CPA

Castaldo CPA

4.8 69 reviews
“They also help us with budgeting and tracking our cost per plate, which has been extremely valuable for managing our business.”
AICPA memberFree consultationSince 2010
Lake Grove, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Ross & Company, CPA

Ross & Company, CPA

5.0 50 reviews
“If you are new in business, or are growing in any direction, than Ross and Company is the firm you'll need to successfully navigate NYS.”
Since 2005Prices online
Smithtown, NY · 14 mi from Brookhaven
i
Rost & Company, Cpas

Rost & Company, Cpas

4.3 16 reviews
“I would definitely recommend them to anybody looking for an honest ,efficient accountant service”
Free consultationSince 2017FinancingPrices online
Ronkonkoma, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Sebastiano Vitelli & Co Accountants & Consultants

Sebastiano Vitelli & Co Accountants & Consultants

5.0 12 reviews
“Making a switch to use him for our business and personal tax returns will be saving us thousands of dollars by utilizing the tax laws that I didn't realize existed.”
BBB ASince 2006
Holbrook, NY · 7 mi from Brookhaven
i
O'Hara & Company

O'Hara & Company

5.0 16 reviews
“I've been a loyal client for many years and they are fast and efficient.”
Since 2007FinancingPrices online
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
John E Helldorfer, CPA

John E Helldorfer, CPA

5.0 33 reviews
“He was able to get me in the next business day to do my personal income taxes.”
Since 2019
Nesconset, NY · 10 mi from Brookhaven
i

The 15 companies listed for Brookhaven, NY keep books, reconcile accounts and close the month for businesses. What each says about its packages and software comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Hiring a bookkeeper near Brookhaven

The 15 companies on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 345 reviews; 2 have 50 or more reviews and 13 are rated 4.5 or higher.

Do any bookkeeping companies listed for Brookhaven offer a free assessment?

A first consultation without charge is stated by 4 of the 15 companies. It usually means someone looks at your file, counts the monthly transactions, and gives you a price. Have login access ready or the quote will be a guess.

What federal rules say about tax preparers and accountants
Peggiann McCoy CPA

Peggiann McCoy CPA

4.7 13 reviews
“I Was truly dreading tax time due to some past complications, but working with Peggi was the best decision I made.”
Since 2007FinancingPrices online
Ronkonkoma, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Howard S Cohen

Howard S Cohen

4.6 26 reviews
“I had been very happy with my previous accountant, but he had to retire and I see why he entrusted Howard to take over the practice.”
LicensedSince 2008
Miller Place, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Ken Higgins, CPA

Ken Higgins, CPA

4.7 9 reviews
“I have had a few accountants in the past, Ken is by far and away the best.”
Since 2009
Smithtown, NY · 14 mi from Brookhaven
i
Book onlineBook
Greg Hudgins, CPA

Greg Hudgins, CPA

5.0 39 reviews
“He is always quick to respond to questions and consistently provides clear, accurate answers—or directs me to the right resource when needed.”
Serves Long Island, New YorkSince 1998
Southampton, NY · 24 mi from Brookhaven
i
Nick J. Giannitsas CPA

Nick J. Giannitsas CPA

4.2 2 reviews
“NICK is awsome, we actually miss our in person appointment with him, he is efficient and always provides excellent service.”
Free consultationSince 2013FinancingPrices online
Nesconset, NY · 10 mi from Brookhaven
i
Kessler Liscia Gonzalez Cpas

Kessler Liscia Gonzalez Cpas

5.0 2 reviews
“We've been going to Rebecca for our taxes for years and have referred friends to her.”
Free consultationSince 2016Prices online
Selden, NY · 5 mi from Brookhaven
i
Thomas W. Lally CPA

Thomas W. Lally CPA

5.0 1 review
“Known Tom for over 20 years, very knowledgeable and responsive.”
Since 2017FinancingPrices online
Ronkonkoma, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
S.O Accounting & Consulting

S.O Accounting & Consulting

5.0 2 reviews
“I appreciate the time Sandra takes to make sure I have all the right information to make informed decisions based on numbers.”
Since 2022Prices online
Patchogue, NY · 5 mi from Brookhaven
i
Peter R. O'Leary, CPA

Peter R. O'Leary, CPA

Since 2013FinancingPrices online
Bohemia, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
HomeBookkeepersNew YorkBrookhaven, NY

Compare Bookkeeping Services near Brookhaven, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Castaldo CPA4.8 · 69 reviews · Lake Grove
FreeSince 2010
Rost & Company, Cpas4.3 · 16 reviews · Ronkonkoma
FreeSince 2017
O'Hara & Company5.0 · 16 reviews · Port Jefferson Station
Since 2007
Nick J. Giannitsas CPA4.2 · 2 reviews · Nesconset
FreeSince 2013
Peggiann McCoy CPA4.7 · 13 reviews · Ronkonkoma
Since 2007
Ross & Company, CPA5.0 · 50 reviews
Since 2005
John E Helldorfer, CPA5.0 · 33 reviews · Nesconset
Since 2019
Kessler Liscia Gonzalez Cpas5.0 · 2 reviews · Selden
FreeSince 2016
Thomas W. Lally CPA5.0 · 1 review · Ronkonkoma
Since 2017
Peter R. O'Leary, CPANo rating yet · Bohemia
Since 2013
Howard S Cohen4.6 · 26 reviews · Miller Place
Since 2008
Greg Hudgins, CPA5.0 · 39 reviews
Since 1998
S.O Accounting & Consulting5.0 · 2 reviews · Patchogue
Since 2022
Since 2006
Ken Higgins, CPA4.7 · 9 reviews · Smithtown
Since 2009

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereWe take no money from the firms we list, and no firm can buy a place or an award.
Checked before listedClosed firms, call centers posing as local law offices and duplicate listings are taken off.
Facts from the sourcePractice areas, languages and free consultations come from each firm's own website, checked against the page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Bookkeepers we compared 709 firms in and around Brookhaven. Each gets a score from its client rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then firms in Brookhaven, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top