Best Payroll Services in Fort Collins, CO

15 companies listed · 14 in Fort Collins · 2 open weekends · all 15 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 15, 2026

Book onlineBook
Eger CPA

Eger CPA

4.8 99 reviews
“One of the best CPA's in the area!”
Virtual consultationsServes Northern Colorado13+ yearsFree consultationBBB accreditedFamily-owned
2726 Illinois Dr #201
i
Book onlineBook
Payroll Vault

Payroll Vault

5.0 53 reviews
“He and Amber have made the transition so easy and convenient for me - I should have done this a long time ago.”
Free estimatesServes Ault, CO, Boulder, CO +10Since 2018
325 Cherry St UNIT 112
i
Journey Payroll & HR

Journey Payroll & HR

4.7 45 reviews
“The team at Journey Payroll & HR are great, knowledgeable, supportive, and non judgmental during my organization's transition to Journey for our payroll.”
Nationwide serviceSince 2010BBB A+
3351 Eastbrook Dr Unit 3
i
Momentum Tax & Financial

Momentum Tax & Financial

4.9 31 reviews
“We would be completely lost without Momentum's help, from tax prep to running payroll for our business, etc.”
Free consultationBBB A+Since 2018
200 S Mason St
i
Key2 Accounting

Key2 Accounting

5.0 20 reviews
“I would highly consider them for all your personal and business taxes,accounting and payroll needs.”
Since 2013BBB A+
375 E Horsetooth Rd Suite 2-202
i
Accounting Matters Dba Benchmark Strategic Associates

Accounting Matters Dba Benchmark Strategic Associates

4.9 14 reviews
“We hired Accounting Matters to take care of our company's payroll, we were so pleased with their professionalism, responsiveness and dependability ...”
BBB A+Since 2014
155 Boardwalk Dr Ste 250
i

The 15 companies listed for Fort Collins, CO run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Outsourcing payroll in Fort Collins

14 of the 15 companies we list are based in Fort Collins; the other one does not publish an address. The companies on this page are rated from 4.5 to 5.0 across 408 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Which payroll companies listed for Fort Collins publish service details?

All 15 companies on this page have a website on file. Most list the platforms they run and whether timekeeping, benefits administration and human resources support are sold alongside payroll. Everything stated there is the company's own description.

Unify Payroll

Unify Payroll

5.0 13 reviews
“Everytime I have a a question they are more than willing to help me, either by walking me through how to navigate the payroll website or by doing it for me.”
Free estimatesSame-day responseServes ColoradoBBB A+Since 2018
185 N College Ave
i
Parable Church Accounting and Bookkeeping

Parable Church Accounting and Bookkeeping

4.9 26 reviews
“Their systems for accounting and payroll are so easy to operate under and so aligned with our desires to have standards of excellence, ease, and integrity in the area of church finances.”
Free consultationSince 2020
155 Boardwalk Dr #444
i
Book onlineBook
Payroll Vault Fort Collins

Payroll Vault Fort Collins

5.0 14 reviews
“She is prompt in every reply and there is rarely a question that she does not have the answer to...”
Virtual consultationsServes OahuSince 2018Locally owned
375 E Horsetooth Rd Suite 2-202
i
Book onlineBook
Avid Payroll

Avid Payroll

5.0 9 reviews
“We have worked with Avid's payroll team since its inception and could not be happier!”
Serves ColoradoFree consultationSince 2021
2726 Illinois Dr #201
i
First Priority Payroll

First Priority Payroll

5.0 6 reviews
“And they dummy-proof your payroll so it's impossible to mess it up.”
347+ clients servedServes United StatesSince 2001BBB A+
4730 S College Ave #206
i
Bean Counter Bookkeeping

Bean Counter Bookkeeping

4.8 21 reviews
“She has been helping our company with Accounting and Payroll services for several years and I have been totally satisfied.”
Free consultationSince 2006
3932 John F Kennedy Pkwy
i
RLR

RLR

4.5 6 reviews
“RLR has been handling my small business and personal taxes for two years now and I couldn't be happier.”
Since 2020Prices online
1235 Riverside Ave
i
Steven J Wick & Associates

Steven J Wick & Associates

5.0 8 reviews
“Steve and his team are always courteous, on the ball and speak simple to help us manage our small business finances and taxes.”
Serves Fort Collins, Northern Colorado20+ years
2809 E Harmony Rd # 120
i
Colorado Payroll Services

Colorado Payroll Services

5.0 15 reviews
“By far the best and most straightforward payroll company I have ever dealt with, including internal teams.”
Free consultationSince 2017
Loveland, CO · 9 mi from Fort Collins
i
HomePayroll CompaniesColoradoFort Collins, CO

Compare Payroll Services in Fort Collins, CO

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Payroll Vault5.0 · 53 reviews
FreeSince 2018Free consultation
Parable Church Accounting and Bookkeeping4.9 · 26 reviews
FreeSince 2020Free consultation
Bean Counter Bookkeeping4.8 · 21 reviews
FreeSince 2006Free consultation
Eger CPA4.8 · 99 reviews
Free13+ years
Momentum Tax & Financial4.9 · 31 reviews
FreeSince 2018
Colorado Payroll Services5.0 · 15 reviews
FreeSince 2017
Avid Payroll5.0 · 9 reviews
FreeSince 2021
Key2 Accounting5.0 · 20 reviews
Since 2013
Payroll Vault Fort Collins5.0 · 14 reviews
Since 2018
Journey Payroll & HR4.7 · 45 reviews
Since 2010
Unify Payroll5.0 · 13 reviews
Since 2018
Accounting Matters Dba Benchmark Strategic Associates4.9 · 14 reviews
Since 2014
Steven J Wick & Associates5.0 · 8 reviews
20+ years
First Priority Payroll5.0 · 6 reviews
Since 2001
RLR4.5 · 6 reviews
Since 2020

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereWe take no money from the firms we list, and no firm can buy a place or an award.
Checked before listedClosed firms, call centers posing as local law offices and duplicate listings are taken off.
Facts from the sourcePractice areas, languages and free consultations come from each firm's own website, checked against the page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Payroll Companies we compared 83 firms in and around Fort Collins. Each gets a score from its client rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then firms in Fort Collins, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

What clients say about companies in Fort Collins

  • “Ashley makes everything easy and stress-free, and I can’t recommend her and her team enough for any small business that needs reliable, friendly payroll support.” — client of Payroll Vault
  • “Journey Payroll sets the bar high with their exceptional service, attention to detail, and reliability.” — client of Journey Payroll & HR
  • “Within a week of signing on with them they had my entire business budget, cash flow projections, payroll, taxes all handled and organized.” — client of Momentum Tax & Financial
  • “Being able to delegate payroll to their professional staff has freed up time for us to grow and develop our business.” — client of Avid Payroll
  • “The customer service has been helpful and responsive, and allowed me to focus on running my business rather than payroll deadlines and reporting.” — client of Payroll Vault

Excerpts from public reviews of the companies listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top