Best Car Accident Lawyers in Rochester, NY

23 firms listed · all 23 in Rochester · 5 open 24/7 · 7 open weekends · 18 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 7, 2026

Segar & Sciortino

Segar & Sciortino

4.6 108 reviews
“I will always recommend Segar & Sciortino and specifically Jason Poselovich to family and friends who need a reliable, trustworthy, professional and affordable lawyer.”
Free phone consultationNo fee unless you winServes Western New YorkSince 1993BBB A+Prices online
400 Meridian Centre Blvd Suite 320
i
King Law: Criminal Defense & Personal Injury Firm

King Law: Criminal Defense & Personal Injury Firm

4.9 95 reviews
“Attorney Fazili met with my father and I for a consultation after a car accident and his professionalism and understanding went a long way.”
Free consultation4 attorneysServes Western New YorkOpen 24 hoursSince 2013
650 Clinton Square
i
Law Office of Adam J. Willman

Law Office of Adam J. Willman

4.6 68 reviews
“I have had to use them 3-4 times for traffic tickets and did great at reducing every single ticket!!”
Open 24 hoursSince 2019
45 Exchange Blvd 4th Floor
i
John Wright Law Firm

John Wright Law Firm

5.0 100 reviews
“I truly believe John Wright is the best car accident attorney in Rochester.”
Free consultationOpen 24 hoursSince 2020
16 W Main St
i
Parisi & Bellavia Law

Parisi & Bellavia Law

4.7 117 reviews
“I would've never thought to get a lawyer for a somewhat minor car accident but I am super glad I did because I ended up with fractured ribs, strained neck and I was completely shocked at how much they were able to get me .”
Free phone consultation3 attorneysServes RochesterOpen 24 hoursSince 2012
140 Allens Creek Rd Suite 210
i
Ganguly Brothers Misula

Ganguly Brothers Misula

4.7 60 reviews
“We have used them for multiple real estate closings and recently a will, which they graciously did for free for healthcare workers!”
Since 2013
140 Allens Creek Rd STE 220
i

The 23 firms listed for Rochester, NY handle car accident claims. What they state about collision work, consultations and fee arrangements is drawn from their own websites, while ratings and quoted comments come from public reviews.

Hiring a car accident lawyer in Rochester

All 23 firms we list here are in Rochester itself. We have 24 firms in Rochester on file; this page shows the highest-rated 23. The firms on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 1,362 reviews; 8 have 50 or more reviews and 18 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "results" and "expertise".

Which car accident firms listed for Rochester offer free case reviews?

9 of the 23 firms on this page state that a first case review costs nothing. Bring the police report number, your photos and whatever the insurer has sent. A free review tells you whether the firm wants the case, and what the fee arrangement would look like if you went ahead.

Before you call: what to check and what to ask
Faraci Lange

Faraci Lange

4.6 65 reviews
“When you have serious injuries, it is so nice to take the legal part and turn them over to Faraci Lange and not have to worry about those issues.”
Free consultationSince 1996
1882 S Winton Rd #1
i
Vincent J Criscuolo & Associates

Vincent J Criscuolo & Associates

4.9 72 reviews
“Always professional and upfront and trustworthy and transparent; the firm exceeded my expectations.”
New York Bar since 19843 attorneysServes Rochester36+ years
130 W Main St #220
i
The Marasco Law Firm

The Marasco Law Firm

5.0 31 reviews
“He's truly a life savor and will ONLY use him in the future!”
Free consultationOpen 24 hoursSince 2006
649 Park Ave
i
Rinere & Rinere

Rinere & Rinere

4.7 13 reviews
“He and his assistant, Dee, go above and beyond.”
Free consultationServes Rochester, Monroe County +3BBB A+Since 1995
36 W Main St #798
i
Fitzsimmons, Nunn & Plukas

Fitzsimmons, Nunn & Plukas

4.3 20 reviews
“Was very responsive and supportive concerning senior care, and proactive in taking care of estate issues, always with the family's best interests as priority.”
Serves Rochester, Western New YorkSince 1926
957 Panorama Trail S Suite 100
i
Dellefave Law

Dellefave Law

4.7 17 reviews
“I can't thank him enough for his honesty, direct approach throughout the process and for resolving it as he did.”
Since 1953
45 Exchange Blvd Ste. 923
i
Pamela Halpin Attorney at Law

Pamela Halpin Attorney at Law

4.8 17 reviews
“I have received great legal support as I've worked with Panera Halpin over the years.”
Free consultationServes Greece, surrounding countiesSince 2022
1100 Long Pond Rd
i
McConville Considine Cooman & Morin

McConville Considine Cooman & Morin

4.7 27 reviews
“I've worked with both Peter Gregory and Bill Brueckner, both of whom are excellent and helped me tremendously.”
Virtual consultationsServes Western New York, Central New York +3Since 1979
300 Meridian Centre Blvd Suite 110
i
Morris & Morris Attorneys

Morris & Morris Attorneys

4.8 13 reviews
“They were so responsive, answered emails at all hours of the day and even brought paperwork to my house to be signed when I wasn't able to make it to the office.”
No fee unless you winSe habla español75+ years
120 Corporate Woods #240
i
Philippone Law Office

Philippone Law Office

4.2 10 reviews
“James and Martin Philippone and the entire law office were extremely compassionate, friendly, informative and very genuine with the care they showed us.”
No fee unless you winServes New York StateSince 1956
31 E Main St
i
Laduca Law Firm

Laduca Law Firm

4.1 11 reviews
“The lawyer william mcginn does the job and is fairly priced.”
Free consultationSince 2005
366 White Spruce Blvd
i
Sarkis Law Firm

Sarkis Law Firm

New York Bar since 2001Since 2010
140 Allens Creek Rd #3
i
Montemaggi & Associates

Montemaggi & Associates

4.2 2 reviews
“Great firm, Veronica legal assistant has been very helpful to me over the years and I would recommend them!”
Since 2013
130 W Main St #200
i
Viencek Law

Viencek Law

5.0 1 review
New York Bar since 1989Since 1992
290 Linden Oaks
i
Juris Investments

Juris Investments

5.0 1 review
Since 2007
Rochester, NY
i
Anthony A Dinitto Law Firm

Anthony A Dinitto Law Firm

5.0 2 reviews
“He answered all of our questions and saw that everything went smoothly.”
Since 2008
2250 W Ridge Rd
i
Cook E Michael

Cook E Michael

4.3 2 reviews
Since 1972
1151 Titus Ave
i
HomeCar Wreck LawyersNew YorkRochester, NY

Compare Car Accident Lawyers in Rochester, NY

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
John Wright Law Firm5.0 · 100 reviews
FreeSince 2020Personal injuryFree consultation
FreeSince 2013Personal injury · Criminal defense · Mass tort casesFree consultation
Parisi & Bellavia Law4.7 · 117 reviews
Free, by phoneSince 2012Car Accidents · Dog Bites · Medical MalpracticeFree consultation
The Marasco Law Firm5.0 · 31 reviews
FreeSince 2006Wrongful death · Slip and fall accidents
Segar & Sciortino4.6 · 108 reviews
Free, by phoneSince 1993Personal injury · Workers’ compensationFree consultation · No win, no fee
FreeSince 2022Personal Injury · Automobile Accidents · Negligence ClaimsFree consultation
Rinere & Rinere4.7 · 13 reviews
FreeSince 1995Slip and fall cases · Motor vehicle accidentsFree consultation
Morris & Morris Attorneys4.8 · 13 reviews
75+ yearsPersonal injury · Wrongful death · Auto accidentsNo win, no fee
36+ yearsLost/Reduced Wages · Medical Benefits · Section 32
Philippone Law Office4.2 · 10 reviews
Since 1956Personal injury · Wills and estatesNo win, no fee
Laduca Law Firm4.1 · 11 reviews
FreeSince 2005Free consultation
Since 2019
Faraci Lange4.6 · 65 reviews
FreeSince 1996
Since 1979Wills · Trusts · Estate planning
Since 1926Automobile accidents · Defective products
Since 2008
Ganguly Brothers Misula4.7 · 60 reviews
Since 2013
Viencek Law5.0 · 1 review
Since 1992Personal injury · Consumer law injuries and damages
Montemaggi & Associates4.2 · 2 reviews
Since 2013
Sarkis Law FirmNo rating yet
Since 2010Vehicle accidents · Slip and fall injuries
Dellefave Law4.7 · 17 reviews
Since 1953
Juris Investments5.0 · 1 review
Since 2007
Cook E Michael4.3 · 2 reviews
Since 1972

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereWe take no money from the firms we list, and no firm can buy a place or an award.
Checked before listedClosed firms, call centers posing as local law offices and duplicate listings are taken off.
Facts from the sourcePractice areas, languages and free consultations come from each firm's own website, checked against the page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Car Wreck Lawyers we compared 57 firms in and around Rochester. Each gets a score from its client rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then firms in Rochester, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top