Carmel, IN

Popular Cities

Carmel, IN
Join as a Pro

Best Payroll Services in Carmel, IN

24 companies listed · 4 in Carmel · 5 open weekends · 22 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 19, 2026

View Profile
Edgewater CPA Group

Edgewater CPA Group

(20)
  • Payroll
  • Confidence
  • Communication
“Patrick was able to see straight through the challenges; developed a plan; his plan was approved by IRS; and he then established practices going forward for my LLC which help avoid any future discrepencies.”
In Business Since 2018
1 S Rangeline Rd Ste 200, Carmel, IN
i
View Profile
Jayd Advisors - Shelley R Johnson CPA

Jayd Advisors - Shelley R Johnson CPA

(5)
“Has managed my taxes for the past 7 years and has consistently surprised me with the savings she's found.”
In Business Since 2013
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Remote Consultations Available
BBB Rating: A+
11350 N Meridian St #120, Carmel, IN
i
View Profile
Milestone Business Solutions

Milestone Business Solutions

(9)
  • Team
  • Financial
  • Leadership
“I would highly recommend the team, their ability to scale with your needs, and their expertise if you are looking for high quality financial analysis before having an on-staff team member.”
In Business Since 2020
11711 N Meridian St Suite 405, Carmel, IN
i
View Profile
Accura Accountancy

Accura Accountancy

In Business Since 2004
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
BBB Rating: A+
621 N Rangeline Rd, Carmel, IN
i
View Profile
J.R. Helms & Associates

J.R. Helms & Associates

(49)
  • Questions
  • Information
  • Services
“Because of information shared and explained in a way that is easy to understand, my husband and I were able to re-apply for our health insurance and now qualify for PTC which is saving us a good chunk of money every month.”
In Business Since 1998
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
BBB Rating: A+
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
TMA Accounting

TMA Accounting

(50)
  • Small Business
  • Work
  • Questions
“I hired these folks to take over my payroll for two local restaurants, let me just say I used to work with a large national provider and the difference in my experience cannot be overstated.”
In Business Since 2003
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i

The 24 companies listed for Carmel, IN run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Carmel, IN

4 of the 24 companies we list are based in Carmel; the other 20 serve Carmel from towns including Indianapolis (13 mi), Fishers (10 mi) and Westfield (3 mi). 23 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 4.2 to 5.0 across 664 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews and 22 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (93%), responsiveness (74%) and quality (63%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication" and "trust". 5 are open on Saturdays and 2 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are payroll services (3), tax services (3), accounting services (2), additional services (2) and bookkeeping (2). 4 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 13 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 49 years. 1 offers remote or virtual consultations; 1 offers payment plans and 2 offer a free initial consultation. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Which payroll companies listed for Carmel publish service details?

All 24 companies on this page have a website on file. Most list the platforms they run and whether timekeeping, benefits administration and human resources support are sold alongside payroll. Everything stated there is the company's own description.

View Profile
Whitewater Group

Whitewater Group

(50)
  • Questions
  • Financial
  • Information
“After carefully reviewing websites of those that were highly rated and weeding out those that catered solely to business entities, I found Whitewater Group to be the most impressive upon initial telephone contact.”
In Business Since 2006
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Bogard CPA Accounting and Tax Services

Bogard CPA Accounting and Tax Services

(32)
  • Questions
  • Trust
“Heather was instrumental in helping me launch my business and has been spot on month after month for years taking care of all of my accounting and tax needs, allowing me to focus on operation and growth of my business.”
In Business Since 1977
Accepts Check, Debit, Cash, All Major Credit Cards
BBB Accredited
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
A & B Tax Services

A & B Tax Services

(24)
  • Job
“I've been coming to Nicole for 5 years now and she does a great job with my taxes I've never had a delay and I get my return the date she say or before I recommend everyone that files taxes to go to Nicole”
In Business Since 2013
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
BBB Accredited
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Brandon Lindsay, CPA

Brandon Lindsay, CPA

(28)
  • Knowledge
  • Legal
  • Needs
“They've adjusted their normal practice to ensure we were looked after during a time we had a critical deadline, they were helpful and on hand to answer questions, and made sure that the work was completed on time with good quality.”
In Business Since 2017
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Prime Accounting Services

Prime Accounting Services

(31)
  • Questions
  • Knows
  • Needs
“It was helpful to go through my tax documents together as a new customer and he answered all my last minute questions that I was unsure of while preparing for my appointment.”
In Business Since 2012
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Axiom Human Resource Solutions

Axiom Human Resource Solutions

(16)
  • Payroll
  • Email
  • Team
“The way I've seen them treat their clients more like partners in business rather than just a "client <> provider" relationship, has been nothing that I've experienced anywhere else!”
In Business Since 2014
Remote Consultations Available
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Fishers Financials

Fishers Financials

(14)
  • Questions
  • Payroll
  • Tax Return
“Not only were they super responsive to all my questions, the team also helped me with figuring out why i owed so much and getting my paycheck adjusted correctly so I don't owe next year.”
In Business Since 2024
Fishers, IN · 10 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
A.c.t. Services

A.c.t. Services

(14)
  • Team
  • Season
“Sure you could save a few bucks by going to a place like HR Block, but to me it is worth every penny to have peace of mind knowing something as important as taxes are being handled truly professionally.”
In Business Since 2005
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Chamberlain Accounting Solutions

Chamberlain Accounting Solutions

(9)
  • Financial
  • Conversation
  • Needs
“Holli explained the importance of having good bookkeeping practices: it will let me know at any time the current financial health of my business.”
In Business Since 2023
Fishers, IN · 10 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Million & Co

Million & Co

In Business Since 1987
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
Offers Financing Options
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Marietta Cpas

Marietta Cpas

(9)
  • Small Business
“Focused on service delivery, retaining existing clients, and establishing new relationships leaves little time, resources, and energy for all the accounting functions.”
In Business Since 2019
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Wagner & Wetzel CPA Group

Wagner & Wetzel CPA Group

(4)
“Professional, extremely competent in every area and always answer every question throughly.”
In Business Since 2018
Fishers, IN · 10 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
B F Tax Management & Resolution

B F Tax Management & Resolution

(13)
“I've felt overwhelmed and embarrassed by my weaknesses as an entrepreneur (my nail art skills are tops but not so much my accounting and business management!”
In Business Since 2020
Westfield, IN · 3 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
Hamilton Tax & Accounting Services

Hamilton Tax & Accounting Services

(7)
“I've been using these friendly folks to help with my taxes for the last 5 years and they have made the process so easy and quick.”
In Business Since 1999
BBB Rating: A+
Sheridan, IN · 12 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
La Amiga Tax Resolution

La Amiga Tax Resolution

(2)
“The best thing about Indy, I have been a loyal client since 2012 and I have never had any problems, doing taxes is a serious matter and you must trust ONE professional who is always up to date with the current regulations and changes.”
In Business Since 2021
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
McKinley Jones & Associates

McKinley Jones & Associates

(8)
  • Organization
“I'm grateful I've had the opportunity to work with them and firsthand experience how great listeners both Mc Kinley and Genita are- so If you are looking for a tax professional who will actually treat you like a valued person and not just a number li...”
In Business Since 2018
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
Featured

The IRS often sees the transfer of funds as a loan, whether there is a loan agreement or not. This also means there is an implied term and interest payment. When the IRS says a transaction is a loan, what interest rate do they use? Enter AFRs. Here is what you need to know.

i
View Profile
Ameritax Bookkeeping & Payroll

Ameritax Bookkeeping & Payroll

(4)
“He's been doing my taxes for 11 years now and never fails to deliver the best return possible,not to mention his fees are more than fair and returns are fast ,I believe he also offers insurance at a price you can't find anywhere else..”
In Business Since 2014
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Indianapolis, IN · 13 mi from Carmel
i
View Profile
McBride Cpas

McBride Cpas

(5)
“Kala is wonderful to work with, she's detailed-oriented, trustworthy and highly efficient, she listens and truly cares for her clients as well as their business goals, she's willing to be flexible to work with clients' schedules and budgets.”
In Business Since 2020
Free Initial Consultation
1 mi from Carmel
i
HomePayroll CompaniesIndianaCarmel, IN

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?

More Payroll Services in Indiana

Popular in Carmel

, IN

Tools: Payroll Services

Back To Top