Indianapolis, IN

Popular Cities

Indianapolis, IN
Join as a Pro

Best Payroll Services in Indianapolis, IN

24 companies listed · all 24 in Indianapolis · 5 open weekends · 20 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 21, 2026

View Profile
J.R. Helms & Associates

J.R. Helms & Associates

(49)
  • Financial
  • Guide
  • Sound
“The periodic emails that are sent out are actually quite useful for keeping on top of relevant tax news and important reminders as well as raising awareness of more general financial issues of our day.”
BBB Rating: A+
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1998
7960 Zionsville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Asap Payroll Service

Asap Payroll Service

(35)
  • Team
  • Job
  • Price
“I have found the individuals at ASAP Payroll Service to be very personable, providing excellent customer service not only to me and my business, but to employers of all sizes.”
BBB Rating: A+
Offers Financing Options
Locally Owned & Operated
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
8130 S Meridian St Suite 4C, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
TMA Accounting

TMA Accounting

(50)
  • Team
  • Tax Returns
  • Books
“They consistently meet me where I am professionally, and my accountants are always personable, proactive, and approachable, walking with me through my company's inaugural year.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2003
9595 Whitley Dr #102, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Whitewater Group

Whitewater Group

(50)
  • Confidence
  • Communication
  • Tax Laws
“After multiple years of positive experiences with Whitewater Group (thoroughness and attention to detail), this year they went above and beyond by preparing/providing additional documents for the following year.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2006
9247 N Meridian St Suite 107, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Bogard CPA Accounting and Tax Services

Bogard CPA Accounting and Tax Services

(32)
  • Trust
  • Questions
“Heather was able to get an amazing return for me, found mistakes H&R Block made the year before (resulting in more $ for me), and she found a mistake my employers were making!”
BBB Accredited
Accepts Check, Debit, Cash, All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1977
650 N Girls School Rd Suite E50, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
A & B Tax Services

A & B Tax Services

(24)
  • Job
“Updated 02/10/2020 Ms Sharree did my tax return and she has the BEST personality she was very helpful and it literally took her about 10 mins to do my return I am a very happy and satisfied customer”
BBB Accredited
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2013
1550 N Arlington Ave, Indianapolis, IN
i

The 24 companies listed for Indianapolis, IN run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Indianapolis, IN

All 24 companies we list here are in Indianapolis itself. We have 27 companies in Indianapolis on file; this page shows the highest-rated 24. 23 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 3.9 to 5.0 across 703 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews and 20 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (93%), responsiveness (80%) and quality (63%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication" and "trust". 5 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are payroll services (4), tax services (4), additional services (2), business services (2) and for small businesses (2). 3 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 17 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1998. 1 offers remote or virtual consultations; 3 offer payment plans; 3 offer a free initial consultation and 2 are family- or locally-owned. We count these figures across the companies on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Can I arrange a consultation online with payroll companies listed for Indianapolis?

7 of the 24 companies take appointment requests through their own website. A company without that option works by phone or email. Have your headcount, pay frequency and the states you employ in ready, because those three numbers produce a quote in one conversation.

View Profile
Lawrie & Dunbar, Cpas

Lawrie & Dunbar, Cpas

(17)
  • Team
  • Email
  • Message
“I have been going to Judd Lawrie CPA Group for several years now with my 65 yrs old mother(Peggy) and we both agree that going to see Judd is like going to Disney World LOL!!!”
Accepts Check, Paypal
Offers Financing Options
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
7855 S Emerson Ave i, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Brandon Lindsay, CPA

Brandon Lindsay, CPA

(28)
  • The Future
  • Financial
  • Trust
“Brandon was referred to me by a very reputable attorney and took me on as a client at the peak of the tax return race and guided me through the records I needed and the process he would use to file my return.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2017
5936 N Keystone Ave #203, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Prime Accounting Services

Prime Accounting Services

(31)
  • Happy
  • Paying
  • Patient
“Tom is very professional and been a great help on keeping me up to date on taxes his services are invaluable and I highly recommend him to anyone who seek tax service.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2012
3815 River Crossing Pkwy #100, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Kristel's Tax & Accounting

Kristel's Tax & Accounting

(13)
  • Company
  • Pay
“I was going to have to pay to file taxes anyway, and I felt better giving my money to a local business rather than a big company, especially if filing with a company online meant I would've had to do it myself.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
In Business Since 1975
8005 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Palmer Accounting Services

Palmer Accounting Services

(12)
  • Information
  • Questions
  • Team
“I had tried a couple different accountants and it was just not a good fit, as soon as I sat down with Terry , I felt comfortable right away, and I trusted her.”
In Business Since 2013
5222 S East St B-1, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Axiom Human Resource Solutions

Axiom Human Resource Solutions

(16)
  • Team
  • Email
  • Payroll
“Every time I call in, I get a real person answering and helping me immediately - such a change from the days when we were with ADP or Paycom and we would be on hold for hours!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Remote Consultations Available
In Business Since 2014
9400 Priority Way W Dr, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Pattar & Co. CPA

Pattar & Co. CPA

(14)
“Gave me excellent advice on how to keep track of my business and personal expenses, gains, losses, etc to get optimum tax return avoiding any conflicts.”
In Business Since 2003
1455 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Featured

Happy Martin Luther King Jr. Day! #MLK Day Today, we honor the legacy of a true visionary who inspired change through love, equality, and justice. Let's continue the journey towards a world where kindness and respect unite us all. 🫱🏽‍🫲🏾 #choosepattar 🔹 #martinlutherkingjr #mlkjrday #indianapolisindiana #indy...

i
View Profile
A.c.t. Services

A.c.t. Services

(14)
  • Season
  • Team
“Their leadership *cares* about the firm's clients and to that end schedules regular meetings for feedback about what they might do better (my typical answer: "Nothing!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2005
5601 W 74th St, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Million & Co

Million & Co

Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
9100 Purdue Rd, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Marietta Cpas

Marietta Cpas

(9)
  • Small Business
“Focused on service delivery, retaining existing clients, and establishing new relationships leaves little time, resources, and energy for all the accounting functions.”
In Business Since 2019
9101 Wesleyan Rd Ste. 300, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
La Amiga Tax Resolution

La Amiga Tax Resolution

(2)
“The best thing about Indy, I have been a loyal client since 2012 and I have never had any problems, doing taxes is a serious matter and you must trust ONE professional who is always up to date with the current regulations and changes.”
In Business Since 2021
3660 Guion Rd Suite 305, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
McKinley Jones & Associates

McKinley Jones & Associates

(8)
  • Organization
“We have used the services of this organization for our nonprofit business for approximately 10 years and have been very happy with the services provided.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2018
5936 N Keystone Ave #203, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Ameritax Bookkeeping & Payroll

Ameritax Bookkeeping & Payroll

(4)
“He's been doing my taxes for 11 years now and never fails to deliver the best return possible,not to mention his fees are more than fair and returns are fast ,I believe he also offers insurance at a price you can't find anywhere else..”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2014
3755 E 82nd St Ste 20, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
The Tax Advantage

The Tax Advantage

(2)
“I highly recommend her to anyone who needs accounting or tax work done.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards, Cash, Check, Debit
In Business Since 2013
450 E 96th St #500, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Circle City Taxes

Circle City Taxes

(2)
“No problem with me....”
In Business Since 2006
2620 N Sherman Dr, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Tacs

Tacs

(4)
“We've used them for three years and they make the process streamlined and very easy for us.”
In Business Since 1983
6508 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
Robert Hodge Tax & Accounting Co

Robert Hodge Tax & Accounting Co

(2)
“Recently, with Bob's guidance, I was able to guide a couple of charitable organizations through some difficult legal challenges that arose from tax issues.”
BBB Rating: A+
941 E 86th St #111, Indianapolis, IN
i
View Profile
JNW Group

JNW Group

In Business Since 2002
8606 Allisonville Rd #109, Indianapolis, IN
i
HomePayroll CompaniesIndianaIndianapolis, IN

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?

More Payroll Services in Indiana

Popular in Indianapolis

, IN

Tools: Payroll Services

Back To Top