Best Payroll and Timekeeping Services in Cincinnati, OH

Handpicked from 113 vetted & reviewed Payroll Administration Processing companies in the Cincinnati area, discover the top 5 standout choices among the selected group of 24 finalists.

Pay Magic

Pay Magic

(2)
“Melody has been such a help in getting my employee's pay secured and organized.”
In Business Since 2019
11260 Chester Rd #560, Cincinnati, OH
i
Seibel & Katz Cpas

Seibel & Katz Cpas

(48)
Certified Public Accounting
“Seibel & Katz CP As have been doing my taxes and answering my questions for a lot of years and I've always been happy with their quick and accurate service and their willingness to take the time to answer what ever questions I have.”
In Business Since 1999
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Free Initial Consultation
3814 West St UNIT 311, Cincinnati, OH
i
LSC | Longschaefer Cpa/Pfs

LSC | Longschaefer Cpa/Pfs

(27)
  • Planning
  • Financial
  • Team
“Long, Schaefer & Company have worked with my business over twenty years - each year earning their keep relieving me of tax worries while increasing my wealth/success.”
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2004
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
3377 Compton Rd Suite 120, Cincinnati, OH
i
Payoptions

Payoptions

(50)
HR Compliance, Payroll, Work Compensation
“In line with that positive culture, Ryan has the ability to hire, manage, and retain good people - - case in point - - James Patterson who is our point person inside of Pay Options.”
In Business Since 2000
Transparent Fees & Pricing
10296 Springfield Pike #300, Cincinnati, OH
i
Professional Payroll Services

Professional Payroll Services

(27)
Payroll Services, Payroll Reports, Basic Payroll Service
“Specifically, Kim has been wonderful in handling any issues and day-to-day procedures that would be challenging for a business owner to handle solo while trying to focus on other daily business tasks.”
In Business Since 1979
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Free Initial Consultation
8832 Reading Rd, Cincinnati, OH
i
Best of 2024

Qualification Criteria for best of Winners

Minimum Overall Score
95 (100)
Minimum Reputation Rank
98.3 Percentile
All of our award winners are based on identifiable facts - reviews, performance, and experience - collected by scientific means. We use this data to assess each business’s essential features, weighting them according to their importance to customers.
Read our methodology
Prominent finalists
Hartlaub CPA

Hartlaub CPA

(27)
  • Questions
“I've been enjoying my relationship with Hartlaub Tax Service since the early '90's and there is a reason I'm still taking their advice - they get it and they ALL think about what's the next move to lessen my tax burden.”
In Business Since 2002
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
11260 Chester Rd #560, Cincinnati, OH
i
Ohio Tax Service

Ohio Tax Service

(3)
Bookkeeping
“While all staff were busy, one advised she would clean off her desk and be with me in a few minutes.”
In Business Since 1942
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Transparent Fees & Pricing
7162 Reading Rd #105, Cincinnati, OH
i
Volz CPA

Volz CPA

Accounting Power, Business Services, Business Taxes
“A BOI report identifies the individuals who own 25 percent or more of the corporation or LLC and then also individuals who have substantial control (like corporate officers and directors, LLC members, LLC managers, etc.) over a corporation or LLC.”
In Business Since 1989
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
9900 Carver Rd # 100, Cincinnati, OH
i
TM Wuebbling

TM Wuebbling

Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2018
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts Check, Cash, All Major Credit Cards
3735 Vollmer Pl, Cincinnati, OH
i
Academy of Business Training

Academy of Business Training

(8)
  • Instructor
  • Understand
  • The Academy
“I completed the Train the Trainer Self-Study course, It is definitely the best course I have ever taken, a 24 modules that cover all area of training , Professor Mark explanations were extremely helpful and his use of videos helped me understand the...”
In Business Since 2012
Licensed, BBB Accredited
Remote Consultations Available
260 Northland Blvd #326, Cincinnati, OH
i
R. J. Molloy Co.

R. J. Molloy Co.

“Our clients get professional assistance to ensures their long-term business and financial success. We help them maximize their cash potential, increases efficiency and minimize their tax liability.”
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 1974
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Transparent Fees & Pricing
3349 Glenmore Ave, Cincinnati, OH
i
Joseph L Pahls CPA

Joseph L Pahls CPA

(9)
Financial Statements, Business Tax Returns, Individuals
“With my difficult taxes I give Joe Pahls accounting firm 5 Stars, My advice, although it may be somber is to find accountant under 65-70 years old, that has a full time accounting day job, and one that your not going to out live so you keep on same p...”
In Business Since 1997
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
9620 Colerain Ave #28, Cincinnati, OH
i
Keys & Simpkinson

Keys & Simpkinson

“Keys & Simpkinson provides tax preparation, bookkeeping and payroll services.”
In Business Since 1990
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
8280 Montgomery Rd # 102, Cincinnati, OH
i
Reiser & Company

Reiser & Company

(1)
Quickbooks®, Tax Resolution, Business Consulting
“Always there to answer my questions - no matter what they are.”
In Business Since 1991
Family Business
1405 Springfield Pike #2, Cincinnati, OH
i
Gutzwiller Tax & Accounting

Gutzwiller Tax & Accounting

(4)
Payroll Services, Accounting, Tax Preparation
“Matt and the staff are very knowledgeable and attentive to my needs as a small business.”
In Business Since 2017
9109 Montgomery Rd, Cincinnati, OH
i
J. Hunter Company

J. Hunter Company

(5)
  • Books
“When I started my business 3 years ago, I knew I needed someone who could help me to not drown in the details of the accounting, which is not my strong suit.”
In Business Since 1996
Free Initial Consultation
3571 Columbia Pkwy, Cincinnati, OH
i
Riesenbeck Robert CPA

Riesenbeck Robert CPA

(2)
“Rob provides excellent business tax return service and is always willing to answer any questions that you have.”
In Business Since 2005
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
6020 Harrison Ave # 9, Cincinnati, OH
i
Vari Tax Service

Vari Tax Service

(2)
“I highly recommend his services to anyone in need.”
In Business Since 2018
9745 Mangham Dr, Cincinnati, OH
i
Cornerstone Insurance and Financial Services,inc.

Cornerstone Insurance and Financial Services,inc.

(2)
“We are very pleased with the group medical plan we have, and more importantly, the annual research and guidance we receive on the best renewal options to keep our costs low, but maintain excellent benefits for our team.”
In Business Since 2007
9200 Montgomery Rd Bldg.E, Suite 17B, Cincinnati, OH
i
Maintenance Methods

Maintenance Methods

“For over 60 years, Maintenance Methods has been providing clients with comprehensive solutions for their payroll, accounting, and consulting needs. Our experienced team of professionals has been formed to provide high-quality and personalized service...”
In Business Since 1963
1 Crosley Field Lane, Suite #1, Cincinnati, OH
i
Cincinnati Time

Cincinnati Time

(2)
“T Ime card, key card, door entry and more.”
9959 Cincinnati Dayton Rd, West Chester Township, OH 45069
i
Payroll Partners

Payroll Partners

(50)
  • Calls
  • Patient
  • Client Experience
“The process has been very smooth with Payroll Partners so far and Kailin specifically was very helpful in getting us onboarded and communicating very well.”
In Business Since 2008
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts Debit
Serving Cincinnati Area
i
West Chester Tax and Accounting

West Chester Tax and Accounting

(35)
  • Questions
  • Company
  • Price
“Tax season and financials are never scary or intimidating thanks to Steve and Brad, and I always pay the referral forward by referring my friends knowing they are in good hands.”
In Business Since 2018
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Cincinnati Area
i
Midwest Pay Link

Midwest Pay Link

(20)
HR Solutions, Payroll Processing & Payroll Taxes, Digital Onboarding
“Special needs crop up, employee needs change, taxing authorities implement new rules and filing procedures - MPL handles all of this so we can go about running our business.”
In Business Since 1998
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Cincinnati Area
i

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top