View Profile
Notchbooks
- Understand
- Financial
- Team
“We've now been working with him a several years and after doing business with several poor accountants, Ian has definitely given us the ability to sigh a breath of relief.”
Best Payroll Services near Smithtown, NY
3 of these companies are based in Smithtown; the others serve Smithtown from towns including Melville (12 mi), Hauppauge (3 mi) and Central Islip (6 mi).
5 open weekends · all 24 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 18, 2026
View Profile
Edwin Casanova, CPA
- Tax Return
- Stress
- Questions
“I used Edwin to review my solar panel taxes last year and he was able to amend my previous years taxes and get me a few thousand dollars my last guy missed.”
View Profile
Ross & Company, CPA
- Team
- Questions
- Knowledge
“One of the best parts, besides everything described above, is Glen's willingness to answer questions and to offer help throughout the year for any new tax questions at no extra charge (e.”
View Profile
Raisman CPA
- Generations
“I have this respect for Al and the firm because no matter what comes up requiring their services, I know it will be handled proffessionally and thoroughly.”
View Profile
William Carpenter CPA
- Informative
“I have been using him for over 25 years both for my personnel and business needs and I find him honest, hard working and very up on all the new laws and mandates .”
View Profile
Baron Payroll
- Company
“To all the business owners out there, if you are looking for a professional firm that stays on top of your needs and supports your business with outstanding concierge like service, look no further!”
The 24 companies listed for Smithtown, NY run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Smithtown, NY
The 24 companies on this page are rated from 4.6 to 5.0 across 1,460 reviews; 8 have 50 or more reviews. When clients rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (100%), responsiveness (91%) and quality (65%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "knowledge", "communication" and "efficient". 5 are open on Saturdays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are tax services (9), payroll services (6), business services (5), business valuations (3) and bookkeeping (2). 3 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 21 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 59 years. 5 offer payment plans; 5 offer a free initial consultation and 1 lists coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for all 24 of the companies on this page; all 24 publish a contact page; 21 list a public email and 5 take bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.
Why are payroll companies outside Smithtown on this page?
An office in Smithtown is held by 3 of the 24 companies. The rest come from other towns within 20 mi. Payroll is run remotely, so the filing jurisdictions a provider covers matter far more than the address. Distances are straight-line.
View Profile
Zuma Payroll & Processing
- Needs
- Decision
- Professional
“As a Union contractor finding the best fit for your payroll service can be challenging, after losing our previous payroll service of over 25yrs we struggled find a new fit, multiple late nights trying to correct errors was alleviated by an erroneous ...”
View Profile
Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service
- Financial
- 1981
- Questions
“My wife has trusted David Soloway and the Soloway Staff with her personal and business financial matters since the late 90's and brought me along (she demanded) while we were dating in 2010.”
View Profile
Prestigepeo
- Team
- Onboarding
- Payroll
“Working at Prestige Peo has been a great experience for me, I've learned a lot about the world of payroll, worked with awesome people and the team is always there for me when I need them.”
View Profile
Kassman Accounting
- Business Taxes
- The Office
- Team
“He's not only given me a lot of really valuable counsel but also has taken the time to explain his recommendations when I haven't totally understood them.”
View Profile
Long Island Tax, Accounting, & Advisory Services
- Stress
- Knowledge
- Questions
“Not only professionally prepared returns where they went over every detail to get us the best refund, but answering any questions we had during the year and responding in a very timely manner.”
View Profile
Michels & Hanley Cpas
- Communication
- Responsive
- Questions
“They are uniquely focused on the needs of the Small Business Owner and Professional Individuals, and are willing to go the extra mile to ensure that make sure I get the guidance I need for my specific situation.”
View Profile
Edward Helm CPA
“Im highly recommending Ed and his accounting services to all my friends & family as im very satisfied with his professionalism, communication, timely responses, on point knowledge, and friendly customer service.”
View Profile
Premier Payroll Solutions
- Team
- Company
“If you own a restaurant or anything having to do with hospitality then you's be foolish not to talk to Mike or Stacey about having them cover your and take care of your payroll needs.”
View Profile
Ferrera Destefano & Caporusso Certified Public Accountants
“Excellent service from very professional group of accountants and staff.”
View Profile
Edwin Vicente Jr CPA
- Communicate
- Questions
- Patient
“Great Firm, Great guy, Vicente, I was so glad I found him, years ago I will continue to have him handling my accountant needs and will recommend him to my family and friends.”
View Profile
O'Hara & Company
“Wonderful service,very professional, and very nice.”
View Profile
Peggiann McCoy CPA
“Peggy has done my business as well as my wife's and my personal accounting for approximately 20 years.”
View Profile
Central Staff Services
“Very friendly and clean store”
View Profile
King and Associates, CPA
“Quality quick service would recommend them to any of my family members or business associates.”
View Profile
Apex Payroll
“I've started my own company just recently and I just brought on board my first few employees and I've been looking for a good payroll company.”
View Profile
Peter J Bertuglia, CPA
“In addition to my personal finances, Peter created an S-Corp for my small business and facilitated the process start to finish as a trusted, knowledgeable guide.”
View Profile
Comprehensive Hospitality Solutions
- Fines
- Company
- Guru
“I only ever use the bookkeeping services provided by Comprehensive Hospitality Solutions, LLC since they are the most dependable, beneficial, and trustworthy.”
View Profile
Reid - Accountants + Advisors
““ Reid Accountants + Advisors” is the brand name under which Reid CPAs, LLP and Reid Tax & Advisory Services, LLC and its subsidiary entities provide professional services. Reid CPAs, LLP and Reid Tax & Advisory Services, LLC (and its subsidiary enti...”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
