Bookwise Business Solutions
“Excellent service very hopeful amazing people to get your job done anyone need help with any with anything, they are the people to go to”
Best Payroll Services near Bay Shore, NY
1 of these companies is based in Bay Shore; the others serve Bay Shore from towns including Smithtown (9 mi), Hauppauge (7 mi) and Melville (9 mi).
6 open weekends · all 15 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
Book onlineBook
Baron Payroll
“I have been with Baron for a few years now and they beat all the payroll companies I have used prior.”
Zuma Payroll & Processing
“David, Katie and Tiffany process my Construction payroll weekly and I am grateful my payroll is in great hands.”
Book onlineBook
Notchbooks
“He does an excellent and thorough job of explaining everything to me and makes sure I understand everything perfectly.”
Edwin Casanova, CPA
“As a self employed person, with complex taxes, Eddie is always knowledgeable and super helpful with all the ins and outs of all things tax related!”
Kassman Accounting
“Great guy, highly suggest going to him for all your tax and accountant needs.”
The 15 companies listed for Bay Shore, NY run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
The 15 companies on this page are rated from 4.6 to 5.0 across 1,828 reviews; 8 have 50 or more reviews. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "knowledge", "efficient" and "communication". 6 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are payroll services (5), tax services (5), bookkeeping (3), business services (3) and advisory services (2). 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 10 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2004. 3 offer payment plans; 3 offer a free initial consultation and 1 lists coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for all 15 of the companies on this page; all 15 publish a contact page; 13 list a public email and 3 take bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.
Can I arrange a consultation online with payroll companies listed for Bay Shore?
3 of the 15 companies take appointment requests through their own website. A company without that option works by phone or email. Have your headcount, pay frequency and the states you employ in ready, because those three numbers produce a quote in one conversation.
Prestigepeo
“I posted once about Prestige PEO but had to send a shout out to Beth Knott for her always being there when I'm having "issues.”
Premier Payroll Solutions
“TJ Sirani is a reliable, personable, and respectable part of this business, and you can't go wrong working with them for your business needs!”
Raisman CPA
“There has never been a time where I could not contact her or get a knowledgeable answer ever.”
Michels & Hanley Cpas
“They took the time to review everything and offered suggestions that really helped me save money on my taxes!”
Ross & Company, CPA
“They also go out of their way to be helpful even when it isn't tax season and you just have a question.”
William Carpenter CPA
“He is right on top of everything and sends the latest information our way.”
John E Helldorfer, CPA
“Helldorfer demonstrated exceptional professionalism, efficiency, and expertise while assisting me with filing my late business tax returns for the 2024 and 2025 tax years.”
Edward Helm CPA
“He is diligent with his work, extremely knowledgeable, responsive and super friendly”
Peggiann McCoy CPA
“Peggy has done my business as well as my wife's and my personal accounting for approximately 20 years.”
Why these companies made our list
What clients say about companies near Bay Shore
- “They are extremely professional and responsive while saving us a considerable amount of money from our last payroll service.” — client of Premier Payroll Solutions
- “Whenever I have a payroll question, I just call the office and one of their courteous and knowledgeable agents helps me and gets me the answers I need right away!” — client of Baron Payroll
- “Zuma is friendly, easy payroll service. Great staff and I would highly recommend using Zuma for processing your payroll.” — client of Zuma Payroll & Processing
- “Baron was super easy to work with for my payroll needs for my small business.” — client of Baron Payroll
- “My questions & issues are responded to immediately. I don’t have to worry about payroll being on time.” — client of Zuma Payroll & Processing
Excerpts from public reviews of the companies listed on this page.
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
