View Profile
Weintraub, Traub, Tracy & Virk Cpas
- Efficient
- Fashion
- Stars
“Having successfully used this reliable firm for more than 30 years to do my family taxes, I had no hesitation to hire them for the non-profit business I manage.”
Best Payroll Services near Bay Shore, NY
These companies serve Bay Shore from nearby bases in towns including Smithtown, Hauppauge and Melville.
24 companies listed · 6 open weekends · 23 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
Baron Payroll
- Company
“To all the business owners out there, if you are looking for a professional firm that stays on top of your needs and supports your business with outstanding concierge like service, look no further!”
View Profile
Zuma Payroll & Processing
- Happy
- Needs
- Reporting
“As a Union contractor finding the best fit for your payroll service can be challenging, after losing our previous payroll service of over 25yrs we struggled find a new fit, multiple late nights trying to correct errors was alleviated by an erroneous ...”
View Profile
Notchbooks
- Small Business
- Understand
- Meeting
“Ian has been very helpful with our filings and planning advice, as needed, helping us to understand the implications of tax law on our current and future decisions.”
View Profile
Alfonso J. Mollica CPA
- Knowledge
- Patient
- Documents
“Pretty is the best 👍👍👍 …”
View Profile
Edwin Casanova, CPA
- Understanding
- Tax Return
- Efficient
“I have not been the most organized and punctual person to work with through the years but always met with patience and understanding from Edwin and Elise.”
The 24 companies listed for Bay Shore, NY run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
The 24 companies on this page are rated from 4.4 to 5.0 across 1,726 reviews; 9 have 50 or more reviews and 23 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (100%), responsiveness (92%) and quality (68%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "knowledge", "efficient" and "communication". 6 are open on Saturdays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are tax services (9), business services (7), payroll services (5), industries (3) and quickbooks services (3). 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 20 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1995. 7 offer payment plans; 6 offer a free initial consultation and 1 lists coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for all 24 of the companies on this page; all 24 publish a contact page; 21 list a public email and 5 take bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.
Can I arrange a consultation online with payroll companies listed for Bay Shore?
5 of the 24 companies take appointment requests through their own website. A company without that option works by phone or email. Have your headcount, pay frequency and the states you employ in ready, because those three numbers produce a quote in one conversation.
View Profile
Prestigepeo
- Benefits
- Team
- Knowledge
“Toniann has been the best HR partner we've had the pleasure of working with , always responds to any inquiries super quick and has been able to guide us in the right direction!”
View Profile
Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service
- Tax Returns
- Financial
- Expertise
“" She can be relied upon to provide accurate information within the confines of tax laws that are in place and constantly informs us of any changes that may help or hurt us in our filings.”
View Profile
Ross & Company, CPA
- Responsive
- Team
- Information
“We dedicated countless hours and worked very hard on our store stocking our virtual shelves and shipping thousands of packages to customers across the country.”
View Profile
Kassman Accounting
- Tax Return
- Business Taxes
- Efficient
“I've had a business for 19 years and dealt with other accountants that didn't have the knowledge and understanding of the right things to do for me.”
View Profile
Long Island Tax, Accounting, & Advisory Services
- Team
- Stress
- Tax Returns
“I am so happy I found long Island tax and accounting I had years of back taxes that they helped with and I am finally free of the fear of oweing the government money they are the best”
View Profile
Accu Data Workforce Solutions
- Reporting
- Company
- HR
“They have provided us with effective training, clear, understandable direction and answers to our ever continuing questions in a extremely timely manner.”
View Profile
Raisman CPA
- Generations
“I have this respect for Al and the firm because no matter what comes up requiring their services, I know it will be handled proffessionally and thoroughly.”
View Profile
Michels & Hanley Cpas
- Small Business
- Communication
- Company
“The whole staff is always there for me to answer any questions I have and I never have to wait days for someone to send me reports I may need or just give me simple advice.”
View Profile
Gupta Tax & Business Services
- Questions
“Gupta Tax has been doing accounting for my company for 7 years now, they have an extremely professional and sincere approach to the jobs which they undertake .”
View Profile
Hyton Accounting & Consulting
- Efficient
- Income
- Filing
“It's worth it to use Hyton Accounting to take care of your tax and accounting needs than to try to save money and deal with the stress, headache and mistakes on your returns.”
View Profile
William Carpenter CPA
- Informative
“I have been using him for over 25 years both for my personnel and business needs and I find him honest, hard working and very up on all the new laws and mandates .”
View Profile
Edward Helm CPA
“Im highly recommending Ed and his accounting services to all my friends & family as im very satisfied with his professionalism, communication, timely responses, on point knowledge, and friendly customer service.”
View Profile
Premier Payroll Solutions
- Team
- Company
“If you own a restaurant or anything having to do with hospitality then you's be foolish not to talk to Mike or Stacey about having them cover your and take care of your payroll needs.”
View Profile
Edwin Vicente Jr CPA
- Communicate
- Questions
- Patient
“Great Firm, Great guy, Vicente, I was so glad I found him, years ago I will continue to have him handling my accountant needs and will recommend him to my family and friends.”
View Profile
Ferrera Destefano & Caporusso Certified Public Accountants
“Excellent service from very professional group of accountants and staff.”
View Profile
Peggiann McCoy CPA
“Caring Personal /Professional Attention that's what the CPA stands for after her name”
View Profile
O'Hara & Company
“Extremely satisfied with their services.”
View Profile
Central Staff Services
“Very friendly and clean store”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
