Best Bookkeeping Services in Toms River, NJ

24 companies listed · 4 in Toms River · 1 open weekends · 22 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

Overhead Solutions Group - CPA and Tax Services

Overhead Solutions Group - CPA and Tax Services

(35)
  • Non-Profit
  • File
  • Portal
“She is very knowledgeable, in my case we don't even live in the same state but she met with me with great flexibility in order to get all the information she needed to save me as much money as possible.”
In Business Since 2021
2 NJ-37 STE F #1082, Toms River, NJ
i
MP McDermott & Associates

MP McDermott & Associates

(2)
“Proud to call Mike Mc Dermott my CPA for business, personal and tax advice for over 20 years!”
In Business Since 2013
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
801-A Main St, Toms River, NJ
i
Colletti, Hearne & Company

Colletti, Hearne & Company

(2)
“We run a small consulting business and the C&H team have always been both totally professional and still personable, friendly and easy to work with.”
In Business Since 2008
Transparent Fees & Pricing
325 W Water St, Toms River, NJ
i
Errion Mark CPA

Errion Mark CPA

(6)
  • Questions
“I was forced to compile all of last year's taxes in a very short period of time.”
In Business Since 2010
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
Serving Toms River Area
i
Shore Point Accounting

Shore Point Accounting

(3)
“Jennifer is detail oriented, has a strong work ethic and I value her personal and professional integrity!”
In Business Since 2013
Serving Toms River Area
i
P&L Bookkeeping & Tax Associates

P&L Bookkeeping & Tax Associates

(3)
“I've been with her for years, since early in my marriage when home ownershop and everything became too much for me to do my own taxes.”
1285 Delaware Ave, Toms River, NJ
i

The 24 companies listed for Toms River, NJ keep books, reconcile accounts and close the month for businesses. What each says about its packages and software comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Toms River, NJ

4 of the 24 companies we list are based in Toms River; the other 20 serve Toms River from towns including Brick (6 mi), Lakewood (6 mi) and Bayville (5 mi). The companies on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 542 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews and 22 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (93%), responsiveness (74%) and quality (70%). 1 is open on Saturdays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are bookkeeping (4), payroll (3), business services (2), new business formation (2) and non-profit organizations (2). 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 12 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2000. 1 offers remote or virtual consultations; 4 offer payment plans; 6 offer a free initial consultation and 2 are family- or locally-owned. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Can I request help online from bookkeepers listed for Toms River?

2 of the 24 companies take inquiries or appointment requests through their own website. A company without that option works by phone or email. Whichever you use, say what software you run and roughly how many transactions a month you have. It is what decides the price.

Central Jersey Tax Services

Central Jersey Tax Services

(50)
  • Expertise
  • Preparing
  • Interest
“A real good company all around- The professionals on staff especially, giving simple advice for what we thought was complex, by offering the right business sense to grow our revenue.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2003
BBB Rating: A+
Serving Toms River Area
i
Sharp Payroll Service

Sharp Payroll Service

(50)
  • Bookkeeping
  • Pricing
  • Taxes
“The whole team is extremely helpful and always on hand to answer any questions - everything is explained in a manner that is clear and easy to understand.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2014
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Toms River Area
i
Pfeiffer Accounting & Tax Service

Pfeiffer Accounting & Tax Service

(49)
  • Plan
  • Decision
  • Season
“As a senior citizen I was initially a little concerned about working with someone remotely rather than face to face, but David alleviated those concerns immediately, as he is so clearly committed to providing the best possible service and outcomes.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2009
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
Serving Toms River Area
i
Daniel De Stefano CPA

Daniel De Stefano CPA

(12)
  • Company
“I had a complicated tax situation that he was able to rectify for me and took his time to explain exactly what needed to be done in order to move things along more quickly.”
Free Initial Consultation
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
Remote Consultations Available
223 Drum Point Rd, Brick Township, NJ
i
Joseph Apuzzo, CPA

Joseph Apuzzo, CPA

(9)
  • Honest
  • Questions
“When you become Joe's client, you will soon realize that you and your family are in great hands and you will realize that you are working with someone, who has your best interest in mind and you will soon get this feeling of comfort, security and saf...”
In Business Since 2002
337 Drum Point Rd, Brick Township, NJ
i
John E Geantasio CPA

John E Geantasio CPA

(29)
  • Information
  • Team
  • Questions
“In earlier years I've used turbo tax and H&R block since my taxes were pretty straight forwards, however I was able to maximize my deduction and ended up getting back 2x what I thought!”
In Business Since 2008
Serving Toms River Area
i
Arbor Tax and Accounting Services

Arbor Tax and Accounting Services

(7)
“He is very knowledgeable and continues to provide great insight and financial guidance throughout tax season and beyond.”
20+ Years Experience
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
Serving Toms River Area
i
Jason W. Mercer, CPA

Jason W. Mercer, CPA

(4)
  • Financial
“Despite the complexities of our tax preparation, Jason's expertise consistently ensures we stay ahead of the curve, alleviating any worries we may have had.”
In Business Since 2019
Transparent Fees & Pricing
64 Club House Rd, Brick Township, NJ
i
Rakow and Co

Rakow and Co

(1)
“Chana was such a great and verry friendly person to work with, and helped me so much with my bookkeeping services”
In Business Since 2022
Free Initial Consultation
40 Villanova Dr, Jackson Township, NJ
i
Booktied

Booktied

(5)
“Aidy is very reliable, professional, and prompt.”
In Business Since 2017
1776 Ave of the States 3rd Floor, Lakewood, NJ
i
Tax Preparations by Kamran Arif

Tax Preparations by Kamran Arif

(1)
“Experts!”
In Business Since 2016
618 Windcrest Ct, Brick Township, NJ
i
McCarthy & De Luca

McCarthy & De Luca

(1)
“Tressa at the front desk is always a pleasure to deal with and always so friendly.”
In Business Since 2010
Family Business
Serving Toms River Area
i
Pinit Bookkeeping Services

Pinit Bookkeeping Services

(2)
“Best guy ever on top of his stuff, professional and experienced”
In Business Since 2020
Serving Toms River Area
i
Bookssmart

Bookssmart

(5)
  • Financial
“Mutty was very helpful ,when i started with him my books where a mess now its in prefect order , he always helps me identify where im making the most profit”
In Business Since 2018
5 Stamford Hill Rd, Lakewood, NJ
i
Diane Yusko

Diane Yusko

(1)
“I Called Diane a week ago, made an appointment for Sunday and my Taxes were ready the next day!”
In Business Since 2013
7 Rustic Dr, Howell Township, NJ
i
Howard Epstein Accounting

Howard Epstein Accounting

(2)
“This guy has been doing my taxes for last 15 years and is awesome.”
In Business Since 2013
832 S Lake Dr, Lakewood, NJ
i
LL Books

LL Books

(10)
  • Efficiency
  • Questions
“They are quick, neat, professional, confidential, and are so knowledgeable.”
In Business Since 2022
15 Hastings Ct, Jackson Township, NJ
i
Black Box Payroll

Black Box Payroll

(1)
“Unfortunately some clients do not pay their bills and leave skipping out on multiple months of service (see Jody Torre) then expect priority service for free when they need something.”
In Business Since 2012
BBB Rating: A+
Serving Toms River Area
i
HomeBookkeepersNew JerseyToms River, NJ

Bookkeeping and Controller Services in Toms River, NJ Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$576
Maximum cost
$8571
National Average
$1381
Avg Per Hour Rates
$52
$1036
$2301
Fair price range is based on 536 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $1381
Minimum cost $576
Maximum cost $8571
Avg Per Hour Rates $52

Fair range $1036 to $2301 is based on 536 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top