View Profile
Siben & Siben
“Phil Murphy best lawyer the firm has I know phill very well hes helped me out plenty of times I hope he has a speedy recovery definitely best around every one.”
Best Car Accident Lawyers near Bay Shore, NY
We have 2 firms in Bay Shore on file, and both are on this list, along with 22 from towns including Melville (3, 9 mi), Hauppauge (2, 6 mi) and Smithtown (2, 9 mi).
17 open 24/7 · 18 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 18, 2026
View Profile
The Yankowitz Law Firm
- Case
- Questions
- Surgery
“I am very satisfied with the attention provided, I recommend the service 110%, the attention was very personalized and I am very pleased with the final result.”
View Profile
Marino & Marino
- Law Firm
- Job
- Team
“This is the law firm that you have to trust 400% the best unbelievably lawyers good communication good representation I can't say more they are amazing”
View Profile
Valdivia Law Office
“One of the most prominent and proficient attorneys in the business and very concerned about your well being and committed to getting you full compensation.”
View Profile
Fenley
“I couldn't be happier with the way he handled my situation.”
View Profile
Frank Laine
“For more than a quarter of a century Frank J. Laine, P.C. has represented persons injured in motor vehicle accidents, motorcycle accidents, trip/slip and falls, construction accidents and products liability matters. Our clients are generally referred...”
The 24 firms listed for Bay Shore, NY handle car accident claims. What they state about collision work, consultations and fee arrangements is drawn from their own websites, while ratings and quoted comments come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
23 of the 24 firms on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 3,199 reviews; 20 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these firms on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (99%), responsiveness (89%) and quality (80%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "results", "knowledge" and "understanding". 17 are open around the clock; 18 are open on Saturdays and 17 on Sundays. The practice areas the firms on this page list most often on their websites are wrongful death (9), motorcycle accidents (8), car accidents (7), construction accidents (7) and dog bites (7). 6 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 21 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 100 years. 17 offer urgent consultations; 20 offer a free initial consultation; 2 are family- or locally-owned and 1 lists coupons or special offers. 4 have Spanish-speaking staff. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book a consultation.
Are these car accident firms actually based in Bay Shore?
Of the 24 firms here, 2 keep an office inside Bay Shore. The others come from other towns. Collision claims are largely handled remotely, though an office closer to the court hearing your case can matter later on.
View Profile
The Law Offices of Adam C. Gomerman
- Emails
- Feel
- Patient
“Gomerman offers excellent legal services, which is to be expected, but he goes beyond that and often provides reassurance and peace of mind in knowing you are in great hands.”
View Profile
Rosenberg & Gluck
- Job
- Informative
- Hospital
“The firm took ownership of my case, especially Erin Hargis, everything went nice and smooth, she was always there to answer my questions, concerns and emails in a timely manner”
View Profile
Tonalaw | A Personal Injury Law Firm
- Hands
- Asset
- Matter
“Tona himself called me immediately from his family vacation and set me up with a team of professional , caring people that guided me through my recovery every step of the way.”
View Profile
Cartier, Bernstein, Auerbach & Steinberg
- Legal Advice
- Expertise
- Matter
“I suffered a car accident and he was very detailed throughout the process and made what was an unforgettable experience feel easier with support of all my questions and concerns.”
View Profile
Bragoli & Associates
- Feel
- Team
- Attention
“Bragoli and his staff are very professional, attentive, quick to answer any questions I have, they are always on top of everything, and always guiding me through the whole process.”
View Profile
Roche LAW Group
- Feel
- Questions
- Hiring
“While working w/attorney Olivier Roche he made sure to give precise and detailed instructions throughout the entire duration of my case in order to have all information organized and well prepared.”
View Profile
The Harrison Law Group
- Understanding
- Paralegal
- Communication
“No matter the intricacies of my case, they were able to provide clear and concise guidance, ensuring that I fully understood my options and the potential outcomes.”
View Profile
Walker & Mackenzie
- Results
- Team
- Legal Assistance
“Each member of the team have been so helpful getting us the information we need and assisting us with finding the proper people to get treatment and guidance.”
View Profile
Robinson Yablon Cooper & Bonfante
- Job
- Case
- Interest
“Overall the experience was great and hopefully I'll never need to use him again but if I'm ever injured in an accident again he will be the first and only attorney I'd contact.”
View Profile
Aronow Law
- Bankruptcy
- Payments
- Information
“He literally gave me his cell number and said I could call him anytime and he actually answered my calls every time I had questions or just needed to be talked off the ledge.”
View Profile
Friedman & Simon
- Surgery
- Compassionate
- Patient
“The beginning stages of interaction are some of the most important and I feel confident I enlisted the right assistance with Friedman and Simon from my interactions with Doreen!”
View Profile
The Raimondo Law Firm
- The Future
- Case
- Compassionate
“They took care of all legal aspects from the smallest details to major co concerns and always answered any questions I had in a prompt and professional manner.”
View Profile
Bergman Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff
- Questions
- Team
- Communication
“Mike Bergman when notified about my collision, not only drove 45 miles to see me in the hospital that night , but made me and my family feel like members of his own family .”
View Profile
The Odierno Law Firm Accident and Injury Lawyers
- Attention
- Outcome
- Feel
“I'm glad I came across with the odierno law firm and I must say they knew exactly how to handle my case perfectly and I couldn't be happier with the results.”
View Profile
Militello Law Group
- Job
- Outcome
- Team
“The team never stopped working on my case and finally Once everything got back to normal(semi) with the courts, the team was ready to put this all behind us and get my case settled!”
View Profile
Tucker Lawyers
- Understanding
- Questions
- Feel
“Great group of people lawyers very attentive to client took longer than expected because of covid but lawyers checked in at least monthly just reminded me even though they have other things to do I'm also priority!”
View Profile
Castro & Trodden
- Reduce
- License
- Patient
“My family and I feel truely blessed that my case was represented by Brian in traffic court and has gotten amazing results and, he cares about his clients and wants the best outcome.”
View Profile
Law Office of Carl Maltese
- Law Firm
- Knowledge
- Needs
“My experience with the Law Office of Carl Maltese was exceptional, even though I feel the insurance settlement was unfair as compared to the severity of my injury.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
