View Profile
Siben & Siben
“When a wrinkle appeared, such as an out of state doctor whose inattention to detail threatened our settlement, we were promptly briefed and the situation resolved in our favor in a short amount of time.”
Best Personal Injury Lawyers near Bay Shore, NY
We have 4 firms in Bay Shore on file; 3 of them are on this list, along with 21 from towns including Melville (4, 10 mi), Central Islip (2, 4 mi) and Great Neck (2, 25 mi).
17 open 24/7 · 18 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 18, 2026
View Profile
McIntyre, Donohue, Accardi, Salmonson, & Riordan
- Message
- Call
- Workers Comp
“I had the pleasure of having them providing there top tier expertise and service in my settlement and made sure I was fairly compensated in a timely manner.”
View Profile
The Yankowitz Law Firm
- Call
- Questions
- Case
“When I suffered from a personal injury, and I didn't know how to deal with all of the logistics, Brandon walked me through my case step by step with comprehensive knowledge, and a friendly approach.”
View Profile
Marino & Marino
- Communication
- Job
- Team
“He assessed my current injuries, also considered any possible future treatment that may be needed, and possible losses in finances due to the injuries and accounted for them in the case which helped me get the most.”
View Profile
Valdivia Law Office
“One of the most prominent and proficient attorneys in the business and very concerned about your well being and committed to getting you full compensation.”
View Profile
Fenley
“I couldn't be happier with the way he handled my situation.”
The 24 firms on this page are the personal injury practices listed for Bay Shore, NY. What each states about its injury work, consultations and fee arrangements comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
23 of the 24 firms on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 3,724 reviews; 20 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these firms on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (94%), responsiveness (85%) and quality (76%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "results", "knowledge" and "understanding". 17 are open around the clock; 18 are open on Saturdays and 17 on Sundays. The practice areas the firms on this page list most often on their websites are wrongful death (8), construction accidents (7), dog bites (6), motorcycle accidents (6) and bicycle accidents (5). 5 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 21 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 100 years. 17 offer urgent consultations; 20 offer a free initial consultation; 2 are family- or locally-owned and 1 lists coupons or special offers. 3 have Spanish-speaking staff. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book a consultation.
Why are some injury firms listed outside Bay Shore?
3 of the 24 firms are based in Bay Shore itself. The rest come from other towns. Injury files are largely run by phone, email and mail, so an office a short drive away is often perfectly workable.
View Profile
Frank Laine
“For more than a quarter of a century Frank J. Laine, P.C. has represented persons injured in motor vehicle accidents, motorcycle accidents, trip/slip and falls, construction accidents and products liability matters. Our clients are generally referred...”
View Profile
The Law Offices of Adam C. Gomerman
- Stress
- Call
- Feel
“Straight off the back he explained the many options I had, taking his time to explain to me because I'd never experience something like this before and knew nothing about it.”
View Profile
Rosenberg & Gluck
- Responsive
- Paralegal
- Informative
“Overall, I would give Rob and Rosenberg and Gluck Five Stars and would definitely recommend them to friends and family or anybody looking for a local Law Firm.”
View Profile
Tonalaw | A Personal Injury Law Firm
- Advice
- Knowledge
- Asset
“My friend and colleague for over a decade, I've watched his dynamic entrepreneurial take-charge style develop a hard charging firm with a supportive culture and a team that does excellent work, achieves great results, and truly cares about clients.”
View Profile
Cartier, Bernstein, Auerbach & Steinberg
- Honest
- Outcome
- Expertise
“They have been consistently taking care of our legal needs with excellence, integrity and with the level of care and concern as if they were handling it for themselves.”
View Profile
Robinson Yablon Cooper & Bonfante
- Understanding
- Outcome
- Case
“Along the way he answered every single one of my questions, scheduled meetings to go over things that's were important, and made me feel like my case was his main priority.”
View Profile
Aronow Law
- Court
- Questions
- Payments
“They spent the time with me and made me very comfortable of knowing everything that was going to happen he helped save my home and get back on my feet..”
View Profile
Walker & Mackenzie
- Island
- Questions
- Team
“Walker & Mackenzie is a law firm I would suggest to any person in need of a team that has their back during the challenging times that come a long with being injured during an accident.”
View Profile
The Harrison Law Group
- Legal Representation
- Law Firm
- Paralegal
“All of that is great and should be expected from an attorney, but their core commitment to care for and connect with their clients set them apart from other law firms!”
View Profile
Bragoli & Associates
- Emails
- Questions
- Team
“I would like to give a huge thank you to my attorneys Chris Bragoli and Joe Sorce, my paralegal, Jocelyn Guzman, and the whole team, for being there for me, answering all my questions, taking all my calls, texts, emails, and representing me like I wa...”
View Profile
The Law Office Of David Kaufman
- Intelligent
- Questions
- Case
“In the few times I've had to hire a lawyer I usually find it an extremely stressful experience & that I'm second guessing myself that I picked the right person for the job.”
View Profile
The Raimondo Law Firm
- Results
- Case
- Compassionate
“Michael was very helpful and informative throughout the whole process of my case & he also definitely went above and beyond to get me the best results and compensation that I deserved.”
View Profile
Friedman & Simon
- Legal Representation
- Case
- Compassionate
“I'll recommend Friedman & Simon's to anyone in need of great lawyers, they came through for me as fast as they could process wasn't long at all !!!!!!!”
View Profile
Bergman Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff
- Employees
- Case
- Team
“He truly treats you like family and I've seen these commercials of law firms that fight for their clients but Mr Bergman and his staff ACTUALLY do it as well as returns calls promptly where as I hardly ever heard from my other attorney before switchi...”
View Profile
The Odierno Law Firm Accident and Injury Lawyers
- Understanding
- Team
- Outcome
“The best law firm I've ever worked with they treat you with compassion understanding and always willing to go out their way to do the best for you and to help you love you guys”
View Profile
Law Office of Frank A. Cetero
- Job
- Questions
- Law Firm
“From the first consultation to completing my wife's disability case, he and his staff guided her right through the process, and took any second guessing away.”
View Profile
McGuire, Peláez, Bennett & Belcastro
- Receipt
- Service
- Reduced
“Yeah I'm going to recommend a lawyer for anything, always get a lawyer , this place is awesome no points and just a fine worth the money remember people don't work for free and points or conviction costs way more”
View Profile
Dallas Law
- Compassionate
- Team
- Call
“After moving forward, he and his team kept me informed of what was taking place step by step, while also consistently showing concern for the progress of my health.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
