Bay Shore, NY

Popular Cities

Bay Shore, NY
Join as a Pro

Best Accountants near Bay Shore, NY

We have 4 firms in Bay Shore on file; 3 of them are on this list, along with 21 from towns including Melville (4, 10 mi), Massapequa (2, 11 mi) and Central Islip (1, 5 mi).

11 open weekends · 22 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

View Profile
Weintraub, Traub, Tracy & Virk Cpas

Weintraub, Traub, Tracy & Virk Cpas

(39)
  • Job
  • Efficient
  • Stars
“Simply the best Shawn has been help me and his professionalism attention to detail,and effort to assist with all of my tax needs,I'm consistently impressed with Shawn assistance”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 1992
37 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY
i
View Profile
Tait's Tax Service INC

Tait's Tax Service INC

(34)
  • Season
  • Needs
  • Accountant
“I used nick to do my taxes, as well as my moms…I used accountants in the past and he was by far the most professional, patient and detailed oriented I ever dealt with…not only that but he was prompt and responsive which is very strange to find during...”
In Business Since 2019
94W W Main St Suite 205, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
View Profile
Sacco Tax Accounting

Sacco Tax Accounting

(25)
  • Fair
“I fill out senior freeze forms left it at north Bergen library and had not received information as to when I should pick up firm there is a due date of October 31.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2010
17 W Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
View Profile
Justin D. Restmeyer CPA

Justin D. Restmeyer CPA

(5)
“Justin is very patient, knowledgeable, and easy to talk to.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2022
1320 N Windsor Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
View Profile
Craig Morris & Co

Craig Morris & Co

“We are a small, client-focused CPA firm. We work with people every day to solve personal and business financial concerns. We do this by satisfying unique needs, which we recognize through our close relationships and intimate knowledge of the clients ...”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 1987
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Notchbooks

Notchbooks

(48)
  • Questions
  • Knowledge
  • Small Business
“I highly recommend this team service if you are single, married, divorce, have kids, multiple jobs, or whatever is going on with you, he will get you on track to achieve your goals.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2016
34 E Main St #203, Smithtown, NY
i

The 24 firms listed for Bay Shore, NY prepare accounts, statements and returns for businesses and individuals. What each says about its services and software comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Bay Shore, NY

23 of the 24 firms on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 1,796 reviews; 11 have 50 or more reviews and 22 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these firms on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (97%), responsiveness (83%) and quality (81%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "knowledge", "efficient" and "attention to detail". 11 are open on Saturdays and 3 on Sundays. The services the firms on this page list most often on their websites are tax services (8), business services (7), services for individuals (5), quickbooks services (4) and services for quickbooks (4). 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 17 websites of the firms on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1995. 8 offer payment plans; 9 offer a free initial consultation and 1 lists coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for all 24 of the firms on this page; 23 publish a contact page; 18 list a public email and 6 take bookings online. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book a consultation.

Why are accounting firms outside Bay Shore listed on this page?

Inside Bay Shore itself the count is 3 of the 24 firms. The remainder come from other towns within 20 mi. Accounting work travels well, so the relevant question is usually state and industry rather than distance. Distances are straight-line.

View Profile
Alfonso J. Mollica CPA

Alfonso J. Mollica CPA

(49)
  • Team
  • Happy
  • Knowledge
“My taxes were explained and my accountant was super sweet and answered all my questions.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2010
96 Gardiners Ave, Levittown, NY
i
View Profile
Lindenhurst CPA

Lindenhurst CPA

(43)
  • Tax Return
  • Needs
  • Prep
“And if I would recommend anyone for this job I am telling you wholeheartedly and let Christ be my witness that he would be the answer you would want to seek for any tax related purposes”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
Remote Consultations Available
In Business Since 2021
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Ross & Company, CPA

Ross & Company, CPA

(50)
  • Knowledge
  • Tax Returns
  • Responsive
“In addition to being my most trusted CPA I also consider him a super sound and very relatable advisor and friend and I sleep super sound at night knowing that I've got him in my proverbial pocket.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2005
352, Mount Pleasant, SC,
i
View Profile
Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service

Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service

(50)
  • Team
  • Information
  • Tax Returns
“Alisa has been doing my Taxes for about 10 ++years, her knowledge of the tax laws combined with her great personality lessens the pain of this wonderful annual experience of paying the government our hard earned money.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1967
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Taxmaster of Melville

Taxmaster of Melville

(50)
  • Accountant
  • Tax Laws
  • Team
“It's great to have a tax professional reach out to me all during the year to update me on any tax changes or just to touch base to make sure I am on track with what we planned.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1998
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Kassman Accounting

Kassman Accounting

(49)
  • Questions
  • Financial
  • Tax Return
“Myles is extremely knowledgeable and with his expertise you can save a lot of money Don't pay for promises Kassman and Company delivers I strongly recommend them”
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2010
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
SMG ABA

SMG ABA

(50)
  • Financial
  • Industry
  • Management
“I have tried to pinch pennies here and there to run a profitable business and have been very successful in those areas but it took me a while to learn that I didn't want to skimp or short change my accounting team as they have saved and helped me mak...”
In Business Since 2021
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Saranto Calamas Office

Saranto Calamas Office

(32)
  • Job
  • Money
  • Decision
“I have used several accounting services in my life but none combine the up to the minute knowledgeable accounting with old time friendly customer service that you won't find anywhere.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 1999
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
James Castaldo CPA & Associates

James Castaldo CPA & Associates

(49)
“James Castaldo has been preparing my taxes for several years, with great planning James has been saving me more money on my taxes than my overall fee, I recommend James Castaldo to all my friends and I get constant compliments on his results.”
Accepts Debit, Check, All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2010
Serving Bay Shore Area
Featured

James Castaldo CPA & Associates is honored to receive The Clutch Award for Top Accounting Firms in New York City 2022. We continually strive to provide our valued clients with the best accounting and tax services. Thank you for taking us to the top!

i
View Profile
Bookkeeper360

Bookkeeper360

(45)
“!! From my Onboarding Crew who helped me through a TOUGH transition (Hailey Ford and Dave Bornt) to our Tax Prep team who juggles A LOT for us (Ryan Anvari and Hiram Chan) to Brandon Cooperman and Steven Muller”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2006
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Herman P Ortiz CPA

Herman P Ortiz CPA

(26)
  • Informative
  • Tax Returns
  • Financial
“Ortiz's services and vast knowledge of the extensive US tax codes & laws were a huge help when starting my business in 2014 and would not have been able to get started without him.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2016
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Long Island Tax, Accounting, & Advisory Services

Long Island Tax, Accounting, & Advisory Services

(44)
  • Communication
  • Payroll
  • Team
“The personal service I received made me feel valued as a client and I recommend their services to everyone I know who is tired of receiving sub-par service from their tax and accounting provider.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2016
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Gurparsad

Gurparsad

(19)
  • Season
  • Knowledge
  • Questions
“If you're a person who is looking for someone with knowledge, experience and just want to have a good and easy process during tax season, Darshan is the guy you need to see.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2022
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Francis Tax and Accounting Service

Francis Tax and Accounting Service

(26)
  • Call
  • Efficient
  • Tax & Accounting
“She reviews your documents in detail and is able to explain in layman's what is required, what you're entitled to and what you can do in the future to better your financial status.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2012
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
O'Neill & Associates

O'Neill & Associates

(22)
  • Tax Advantage
  • Patient
  • Calls
“He saved us $4,800 in Federal taxes in 2022 by suggesting that we get two IRA's”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2020
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Ambrosio & Bellotti, Cpas

Ambrosio & Bellotti, Cpas

(2)
“Very attentive to details and they always go above and beyond!”
BBB Rating: A
Offers Financing Options
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2007
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
Thomas Brown CPA

Thomas Brown CPA

(29)
  • Number
  • Financial
“Thomas Brown and his staff are always courteous, knowledgeable, responsive, appropriate, creative, and helpful and all within the parameters of the rules and regulations governing taxation.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2007
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
View Profile
John Lepore, CPA

John Lepore, CPA

(25)
  • Stress
  • Questions
  • Tax Return
“I found John about a year ago and he has been incredibly helpful, patient, and does a great job explaining and fixed some of those previous mistakes for me as well.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2014
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
HomeAccountants and AuditorsNew YorkBay Shore, NY

Accounting Services in Bay Shore, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$275
Maximum cost
$3000
National Average
$425
Avg Per Hour Rates
$238
$350
$750
Average price range is based on 506 cost profiles
Embed on your site

Your Embed Code

Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $425
Minimum cost $275
Maximum cost $3000
Avg Per Hour Rates $238

Average range $350 to $750 is based on 506 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?

Accountants near Bay Shore

Popular in Bay Shore

, NY
Back To Top