View Profile
Michele Bennett CPA
- Accountant
- Small Business
“She is the best in town and she provides Superior Service!!!!”
Best Payroll Services in Evansville, IN
18 companies listed · 9 in Evansville · 3 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 19, 2026
View Profile
Pay Day Payroll
- Company
“I've worked with them for years and they are the best!”
View Profile
Fourth Street Accounting Solutions
“They are always available to answer questions and make things easy for you so your attention is on operating your business.”
View Profile
John Friend & Co
“Although we're not "big kahuna" clients John spent the time going over every last (painful in our case) detail & always seemed interested in OUR best interests, regardless of the size of our bank account.”
View Profile
Kemper 1st Choice Payroll - Payroll Services
- Job
- Team
- Work
“Kim and the whole group at Kemper Payroll has been a valuable asset to our company by allowing us to continue to grow and we know our payroll is being handled which allows us more time to do other tasks.”
View Profile
Grable CPA & Company - Evansville
- Desk
- Team
- Questions
“Cody is fantastic and does the job right the first time!”
The 18 companies listed for Evansville, IN run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Evansville, IN
9 of the 18 companies we list are based in Evansville; the other 9 serve Evansville from towns including Newburgh (7 mi), Henderson, KY (11 mi) and Mt Vernon (20 mi). 14 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 4.7 to 5.0 across 130 reviews. 3 are open on Saturdays. 4 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 11 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1997. 1 offers payment plans and 6 offer a free initial consultation. We have a website on file for all 18 of the companies on this page; 15 publish a contact page and 10 list a public email. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.
Why are payroll companies outside Evansville on this page?
An office in Evansville is held by 9 of the 18 companies. The rest come from other towns within 60 mi. Payroll is run remotely, so the filing jurisdictions a provider covers matter far more than the address. Distances are straight-line.
View Profile
Komar Accounting
“The BEST people to work with regarding your $$$ They are honest and speak "human " language rather than account language :-) I will trust Frank and his team forever with my personal and busienss finances as well as all of my coaching clients..”
View Profile
Grey Street Advisors
“We feel fortunate to have Richard and his Grey Street crew to guide us in our tax and financial needs.”
View Profile
Clarence W. Utley
View Profile
Qwest Financial Services
View Profile
Barnhill's Accounting & Financial Services
View Profile
Abacus Paysystems
- Company
- Tax
“Very helpful with all the intricacies of the Employee Retention Tax credit.”
View Profile
Home Town Tax
“Beverly is helpful and affordable on the Tax fees.”
View Profile
Buechlein & Associates
“They are always thorough and organized with their work; in addition, they are great communicators and very prompt with responding to any questions.”
View Profile
BHP Tax & Accounting
“There is no better accountant or accounting firm available, in my estimation.”
View Profile
Dartt & Company
View Profile
Permco HR
View Profile
Street's Accounting Service
“They've been doing our taxes for years and we've never had a complaint or an issue.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
