Best Payroll Services in Evansville, IN

10 companies listed · 8 in Evansville · 7 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 19, 2026

Pay Day Payroll

Pay Day Payroll

4.8 20 reviews
“They work with companies large and small and are always there and available to help out whenever I call or email.”
BBB A+Since 2009
4800 University Dr
i
Fourth Street Accounting Solutions

Fourth Street Accounting Solutions

5.0 4 reviews
“They have been the payroll firm for our Company for many years and have always gone above and beyond the call of duty for us.”
Free consultationServes Evansville, across the countryBBB A+Since 1994
215 SE 4th St
i
Grable CPA & Company - Evansville

Grable CPA & Company - Evansville

4.6 22 reviews
“Harlie has been at the front desk every time I arrive, she is very polite, friendly, and helpful with any questions I have.”
Serves Southern IndianaSince 1997
311 N Wabash Ave of Flags
i
Kemper 1st Choice Payroll - Payroll Services

Kemper 1st Choice Payroll - Payroll Services

4.9 33 reviews
“I am not a math or accounting whiz and they always walk me through things and make it very easy.”
Since 2004
7200 Eagle Crest Blvd
i
John Friend & Company

John Friend & Company

4.2 8 reviews
“Although we're not "big kahuna" clients John spent the time going over every last (painful in our case) detail & always seemed interested in OUR best interests, regardless of the size of our bank account.”
Free consultationSince 2001Prices online
1237 Vision Ct Suite 115
i
Komar Accounting

Komar Accounting

4.0 17 reviews
“Timely, professional, so impressed with this team.”
Since 1975
4111 Washington Ave
i

The 10 companies listed for Evansville, IN run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Evansville, IN

8 of the 10 companies we list are based in Evansville; the other 2 serve Evansville from Newburgh (7 mi) and Henderson, KY (11 mi). 9 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 160 reviews; 7 are rated 4.5 or higher. 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 7 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2001. 1 offers payment plans and 3 offer a free initial consultation. We have a website on file for all 10 of the companies on this page; 9 publish a contact page; 6 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Why are payroll companies outside Evansville on this page?

An office in Evansville is held by 8 of the 10 companies. The rest come from other towns within 15 mi. Payroll is run remotely, so the filing jurisdictions a provider covers matter far more than the address. Distances are straight-line.

Grey Street Advisors

Grey Street Advisors

4.9 12 reviews
“Michele Harris is a very professional, experienced, and knowledgable tax consultant and IRS tax resolution professional you can trust 100%.”
Since 1996Virtual consultations
600 N Weinbach Ave Ste 460
i
Clarence W. Utley

Clarence W. Utley

Since 2015
7201 E Virginia St C
i
Barnhill's Accounting & Financial Services

Barnhill's Accounting & Financial Services

Free consultationSince 2021FinancingPrices online
Henderson, KY · 11 mi from Evansville
i
Qwest Financial Services

Qwest Financial Services

Since 2002
Newburgh, IN · 7 mi from Evansville
i
HomePayroll CompaniesIndianaEvansville, IN

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top