Best Payroll Services in Madison, WI

12 companies listed · 6 in Madison · 2 open weekends · 9 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 12, 2026

Wegner Cpas

Wegner Cpas

4.4 21 reviews
“Furthermore, their bookkeeping staff is top-notch, professional and quick, and not the least, as affordable as some of the smaller outfits I've worked with.”
Nationwide serviceSince 1949BBB A+Financing
2921 Landmark Pl Suite 300
i
Organic Payroll

Organic Payroll

5.0 10 reviews
“I cannot speak highly enough about them, and there is nothing bad I can say about our current or past payroll consultants.”
Free consultationSince 2013
8040 Excelsior Dr #300
i
Stelios Payroll

Stelios Payroll

4.9 17 reviews
“Their commitment to using the most up-to-date software not only ensures data security but also simplifies the entire payroll process”
Virtual consultationsSince 2022
34 Schroeder Ct Ste 200
i
Tunji-Lesi CPA

Tunji-Lesi CPA

5.0 2 reviews
“I wanted someone who had years of experience and very knowledgeable but also patient with the average business owner who lacked a basic background in accounting.”
Free consultationAICPA memberServes Madison areaSince 2003
6314 Odana Rd #14
i
My Money Tax and Accounting

My Money Tax and Accounting

3.7 2 reviews
“Knowledgeable and helpful and very affordable”
Virtual consultationsSince 2008
621 N Sherman Ave # B2
i
Payroll Data Services

Payroll Data Services

5.0 1 review
5202 Eastpark Blvd
i

The 12 companies listed for Madison, WI run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Outsourcing payroll in Madison

6 of the 12 companies we list are based in Madison; the other 6 serve Madison from towns including Windsor (9 mi), Cottage Grove (10 mi) and DeForest (11 mi). The companies on this page are rated from 3.5 to 5.0 across 449 reviews; 1 has 50 or more reviews and 9 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication" and "knowledge". We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Why are payroll companies outside Madison on this page?

An office in Madison is held by 6 of the 12 companies. The rest come from other towns within 15 mi. Payroll is run remotely, so the filing jurisdictions a provider covers matter far more than the address. Distances are straight-line.

Beckett Tax & Accounting

Beckett Tax & Accounting

4.8 75 reviews
“I have had Tylor doing my business accounting and taxes the last few years, and could not be happier!”
Since 2002Family-owned
DeForest, WI · 11 mi from Madison
i
David Hennick CPA

David Hennick CPA

5.0 24 reviews
“He helped me with my business taxes my first year and told me things I had no idea of.”
Free consultationSince 2017
Verona, WI · 11 mi from Madison
i
Veium Duane H CPA

Veium Duane H CPA

5.0 11 reviews
“Duane has been my trusted accounting advisor and tax preparer for two decades (if not more) and has helped both my corporation and my family immeasurably in handling all the fine details of tax prep and financial compliance.”
Free phone consultationAICPA memberServes Madison areaSince 2009
Cottage Grove, WI · 10 mi from Madison
i
Accounting Answers

Accounting Answers

4.5 6 reviews
“Mary Beth is always available, helpful and patient with me as a new business owner learning the ropes in an area I am completely unfamiliar.”
CPA certified20+ years
Windsor, WI · 9 mi from Madison
i
MBE Cpas

MBE Cpas

3.5 19 reviews
“I utilize MBE CPAs for my business taxes, payroll administration and investments and they have always done an exceptional job.”
Serves Wisconsin, Arizona +2Since 1979
Sun Prairie, WI · 12 mi from Madison
i
IBC Business Solutions

IBC Business Solutions

4.7 16 reviews
“We have been working with IBC for many years, and could not be more satisfied with their services and attention to detail, they help make our business run smooth and worry free.”
Since 2020
Madison, WI
i
HomePayroll CompaniesWisconsinMadison, WI

Compare Payroll Services in Madison, WI

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
David Hennick CPA5.0 · 24 reviews · Verona
FreeSince 2017
Veium Duane H CPA5.0 · 11 reviews · Cottage Grove
Free, by phoneSince 2009
Organic Payroll5.0 · 10 reviews
FreeSince 2013
Beckett Tax & Accounting4.8 · 75 reviews · DeForest
Since 2002
Tunji-Lesi CPA5.0 · 2 reviews
FreeSince 2003
Stelios Payroll4.9 · 17 reviews
Since 2022
IBC Business Solutions4.7 · 16 reviews
Since 2020
Wegner Cpas4.4 · 21 reviews
Since 1949
Accounting Answers4.5 · 6 reviews · Windsor
20+ years
My Money Tax and Accounting3.7 · 2 reviews
Since 2008
MBE Cpas3.5 · 19 reviews · Sun Prairie
Since 1979
Payroll Data Services5.0 · 1 review

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereWe take no money from the firms we list, and no firm can buy a place or an award.
Checked before listedClosed firms, call centers posing as local law offices and duplicate listings are taken off.
Facts from the sourcePractice areas, languages and free consultations come from each firm's own website, checked against the page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Payroll Companies we compared 55 firms in and around Madison. Each gets a score from its client rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then firms in Madison, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top