Best Payroll Services in Milwaukee, WI

15 companies listed · 11 in Milwaukee · 2 open weekends · 9 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 14, 2026

Metz CPA

Metz CPA

4.9 45 reviews
“As a small business owner, I appreciate having someone who is there to support and guide me through my tax questions and needs.”
Since 1992BBB A+Prices online
3804 W Vliet St
i
Nelson Tax Accounting

Nelson Tax Accounting

4.6 30 reviews
“You can send them all your documents electronically, and they are quick and responsive through email or phone.”
BBB A+Since 1987Prices online
4404 W Oklahoma Ave
i
Howard's Business Solution

Howard's Business Solution

4.9 22 reviews
“Highly recommended, I owed the IRS she helped me out tremendously, 5 star service,”
Since 2006BBB A+
4319 N 76th St Suite 3
i
A1 TAX Services

A1 TAX Services

4.5 25 reviews
“They take their time with you and treat you like family and not just a number.”
Since 2024Virtual consultations
4369 S Howell Ave #202
i
Book onlineBook
AM Accounting and Tax Services

AM Accounting and Tax Services

4.4 19 reviews
“Even though I don't live in the Milwaukee area, their online system makes everything incredibly easy and convenient.”
Free consultationSince 1997
247 W Freshwater Way #310
i
Horizon Tax & Accounting Services

Horizon Tax & Accounting Services

4.8 16 reviews
“This office has excellent experience with all types of transactions; I recommend it to everyone.”
Since 2017
5151 S Howell Ave # E
i

The 15 companies listed for Milwaukee, WI run payroll, filings and timekeeping for employers. Service and software details are taken from each provider's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Outsourcing payroll in Milwaukee

11 of the 15 companies we list are based in Milwaukee; the other 4 serve Milwaukee from towns including West Allis (5 mi), Glendale (6 mi) and Greenfield (7 mi). 13 of the companies on this page have a rating, from 3.8 to 5.0 across 475 reviews; 4 have 50 or more reviews and 9 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "knowledge" and "communication". We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Can I arrange a consultation online with payroll companies listed for Milwaukee?

2 of the 15 companies take appointment requests through their own website. A company without that option works by phone or email. Have your headcount, pay frequency and the states you employ in ready, because those three numbers produce a quote in one conversation.

Tosa Accounting & Tax

Tosa Accounting & Tax

3.8 8 reviews
“They handled all the paper work dealing with our personal and business taxes!”
Serves Wauwatosa, Brookfield, Metro MilwaukeeSince 1985BBB accreditedPrices online
9205 W Center St #214
i
Diversified Management Services

Diversified Management Services

Free consultationServes Milwaukee, WaukeshaSince 2004Prices online
10520 W Bluemound Rd # 106
i
Universal Tax & Bookkeeping

Universal Tax & Bookkeeping

4.4 3 reviews
“Viridiana and her team always very professional, new location and excellent parking”
3847 S Howell Ave
i
Cook Business Services

Cook Business Services

5.0 2 reviews
“Cathy is fabulous to work with, she answers questions honestly so you understand.”
Since 2013
9401 Beloit Rd #300
i
Bossed Enterprises

Bossed Enterprises

Since 2018
1433 N Water St Suite 400
i
The Neal Group

The Neal Group

4.8 48 reviews
“He asks good questions before finalizing the return and gives good advice for reducing taxable income”
Free consultationVirtual consultationsServes Milwaukee, Southeastern Wisconsin, United StatesSince 1984BBB A+
Greenfield, WI · 7 mi from Milwaukee
i
My Online Accountant

My Online Accountant

5.0 70 reviews
“I highly recommend Daniel, Dan and the entire team at My Online Accountant for their outstanding reliability and strategic insight into our financial needs.”
Free consultationPrices online
Glendale, WI · 6 mi from Milwaukee
i
DMS Accounting Services

DMS Accounting Services

5.0 59 reviews
“I've been coming for 3+ years and always have a great experience.”
Virtual consultationsSe habla españolServes Wisconsin, United States20+ years
New Berlin, WI · 8 mi from Milwaukee
i
H&F Accounting & Tax Service

H&F Accounting & Tax Service

4.3 7 reviews
“Jeff Eilman has been very professional and responsive with with our needs.”
Since 1969
West Allis, WI · 5 mi from Milwaukee
i
HomePayroll CompaniesWisconsinMilwaukee, WI

Compare Payroll Services in Milwaukee, WI

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
The Neal Group4.8 · 48 reviews · Greenfield
FreeSince 1984Free consultation
Diversified Management ServicesNo rating yet
FreeSince 2004Free consultation
My Online Accountant5.0 · 70 reviews · Glendale
Free
DMS Accounting Services5.0 · 59 reviews · New Berlin
20+ years
AM Accounting and Tax Services4.4 · 19 reviews
FreeSince 1997Free consultation
Metz CPA4.9 · 45 reviews
Since 1992
Nelson Tax Accounting4.6 · 30 reviews
Since 1987
A1 TAX Services4.5 · 25 reviews
Since 2024
Howard's Business Solution4.9 · 22 reviews
Since 2006
Horizon Tax & Accounting Services4.8 · 16 reviews
Since 2017
Tosa Accounting & Tax3.8 · 8 reviews
Since 1985
Cook Business Services5.0 · 2 reviews
Since 2013
H&F Accounting & Tax Service4.3 · 7 reviews · West Allis
Since 1969
Bossed EnterprisesNo rating yet
Since 2018
Universal Tax & Bookkeeping4.4 · 3 reviews

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereWe take no money from the firms we list, and no firm can buy a place or an award.
Checked before listedClosed firms, call centers posing as local law offices and duplicate listings are taken off.
Facts from the sourcePractice areas, languages and free consultations come from each firm's own website, checked against the page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: open or closed, hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Payroll Companies we compared 88 firms in and around Milwaukee. Each gets a score from its client rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then firms in Milwaukee, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top