Best CPAs near Oyster Bay, NY

1 of these firms is based in Oyster Bay; the others serve Oyster Bay from towns including Melville (5 mi), Levittown (4 mi) and Carle Place (5 mi).

1 open 24/7 · 6 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 21, 2026

Weintraub, Traub, Tracy & Virk Cpas

Weintraub, Traub, Tracy & Virk Cpas

4.9 42 reviews
“RJ Virk has done an outstanding job in preparing the tax return for my charitable organization.”
Free consultationSince 1992FinancingPrices online
111 South St Ste 2
i
Hirsch & Hirsch Certified Public Accountants

Hirsch & Hirsch Certified Public Accountants

4.9 59 reviews
“Warren Hirsch and his team have provided extraordinary knowledge in tax preparation and other financial services.”
BBB A+Since 1987
Lynbrook, NY · 12 mi from Oyster Bay
i
James P. O'Day, CPA

James P. O'Day, CPA

4.5 60 reviews
“Jim & his team have been my Personal & Business CPAs for 25 years, they are the comsumate professionals, knowledgeable, with their clients best interests at heart.”
Since 2008FinancingPrices online
Glen Cove, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Rogg & Kejriwal

Rogg & Kejriwal

5.0 66 reviews
“Disha was very patient with me and went over all the details carefully regardless how long it took, so i greatly appreciate their time and effort and consideration.”
Since 2014FinancingPrices online
Carle Place, NY · 5 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Alfonso J. Mollica CPA

Alfonso J. Mollica CPA

4.9 74 reviews
“We communicated by text and email and it was done quickly and professionally.”
NATP memberVirtual consultationsServes Nassau County, NY, Suffolk County, NY40+ yearsPrices online
Levittown, NY · 4 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Fine & Clear Tax Solutions

Fine & Clear Tax Solutions

4.9 55 reviews
“After years and years of looking for an efficient and effective company that can deliver high quality customer service for my tax problem, the Fine & Clear Tax Solutions company came to my rescue… from a dear friend's referral !”
Free consultationVirtual consultationsServes Nassau County, NY, Suffolk County, NY17+ years
Uniondale, NY · 6 mi from Oyster Bay
i

The 15 firms listed for Oyster Bay, NY are accounting practices that serve businesses and organizations. What each states about its CPA license and assurance work comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Oyster Bay, NY

The 15 firms on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 1,545 reviews; 12 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "knowledge", "patient" and "communication". 1 is open around the clock; 6 are open on Saturdays and 3 on Sundays. The services the firms on this page list most often on their websites are tax services (6), services for individuals (5), business services (4), small business accounting (4) and bookkeeping services (3). 1 lists staff certifications (CPA) and 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. 11 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 39 years. 1 offers urgent consultations; 5 offer payment plans and 6 offer a free initial consultation. We have a website on file for all 15 of the firms on this page; all 15 publish a contact page; 12 list a public email and 3 take bookings online. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book a consultation.

Which CPA firms listed for Oyster Bay list their assurance services?

Website details are held for all 15 firms on this page. Most name the engagement types they perform and the industries they serve, which is the quickest way to see whether audit work is core business or an occasional job for them.

Shah & Pandya CPA

Shah & Pandya CPA

5.0 70 reviews
“Rajesh, Sahil and team have done a stellar job in helping me file my US taxes on time, navigating both my US and India life events, suggesting the right forms and processes.”
Serves all of tri-state areaFree consultationSince 2013
North New Hyde Park, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Kyle F. Lester, CPA

Kyle F. Lester, CPA

5.0 30 reviews
“He was proactive when the business needed to incorporate and has helped with other numerous questions.”
Free consultationOpen 24 hoursSince 2006FinancingPrices online
Melville, NY · 5 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Taxmaster of Melville

Taxmaster of Melville

5.0 130 reviews
“It's great to have a tax professional reach out to me all during the year to update me on any tax changes or just to touch base to make sure I am on track with what we planned.”
New York CPA license #106463Serves Queens, NY, Long Island, NYSince 1950
Melville, NY · 5 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Pinky Ann Thomas CPA (Beancounters Tax & Accounting Services

Pinky Ann Thomas CPA (Beancounters Tax & Accounting Services

5.0 73 reviews
“She is very knowledgeable and efficient in tax preparation and filing and answer all my questions .”
Since 2012
Bellerose, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Capri Tax & Accounting, CPA

Capri Tax & Accounting, CPA

4.9 56 reviews
“I am so happy I have Capri Tax and Accounting as my tax specialists.”
Since 2013
Malverne, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Kinetic CFO

Kinetic CFO

5.0 69 reviews
“We have slightly complicated taxes and they always communicate and handle everything.”
Free consultationSince 2022
Great Neck, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Kelly A. Rohrs, CPA

Kelly A. Rohrs, CPA

5.0 50 reviews
“If you are a business owner or attorney looking for a knowledgeable, reliable, and thorough CPA, look no further.”
Since 2021
Rockville Centre, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Lindenhurst CPA

Lindenhurst CPA

4.0 45 reviews
“He gets you all of your paperwork back promptly and is always available to address any of your concerns through the portal chat or text messaging.”
Free consultationSince 2021Virtual consultationsPrices online
Lindenhurst, NY · 9 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Herman P Ortiz CPA

Herman P Ortiz CPA

4.9 35 reviews
“Anthony and Paolo were very informative, efficient and courteous.”
Since 2016FinancingPrices online
Melville, NY · 5 mi from Oyster Bay
i
HomeCPA FirmsNew YorkOyster Bay, NY

Why these companies made our list

What clients say about firms near Oyster Bay

  • “I’m very grateful for the guidance and highly recommend this firm to anyone looking for a trustworthy and experienced CPA.” — client of James P. O'Day, CPA
  • “Kelly runs an outstanding CPA practice. She is knowledgeable, professional and has wonderful people skills.” — client of Kelly A. Rohrs, CPA
  • “Shah & Pandya CPA have exceeded my expectations for their expert guidance and support over the years, with personal and business tax filing services and financial advice.” — client of Shah & Pandya CPA
  • “Throughout the process, Pinky CPA maintained excellent customer service, patiently explained tax matters, making sure I understood the implications of each decision.” — client of Pinky Ann Thomas CPA (Beancounters Tax & Accounting Services

Excerpts from public reviews of the firms listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top