Best Payroll and Timekeeping Services in Columbus, OH

The highest-rated Payroll Administration Processing companies out of 172 vetted & reviewed in the Columbus area.

WLC Tax Service

WLC Tax Service

(49)
Business Services, Tax Services, Tax Return Drop-Off
“My 2nd year using Wagner as my tex preparer and it has been a amazing experience, he even went as far as giving me a quick tip on how to manage my expense list.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2000
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Transparent Fees & Pricing
6555 Busch Blvd Suite 260, Columbus, OH
i
JC Taxpros Group

JC Taxpros Group

(41)
  • Organized
  • Honesty
  • Company
“I recommended JC Tax Pros to a few friends of mine for their personal and business related tax and accounting needs and they were also extremely impressed with the diligence and effort that was put into their accounts as well.”
In Business Since 2008
5256 Bethel-Reed Pk, Columbus, OH
i
Buckeye CPA

Buckeye CPA

(15)
  • Questions
“Called on the phone asking if there was new client space for this year, unfortunately they were full, but Buckeye tax was extremely professional, had an actual conversation with me, and directed me to what I needed.”
In Business Since 2006
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Transparent Fees & Pricing
4041 N High St, Columbus, OH
i
MD Consulting & Accounting

MD Consulting & Accounting

(22)
Industries, Services For Quickbooks, Services For Individuals
“It's a catch Positive Responsiveness, Professionalism, Value”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2018
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
5677 Emporium Square, Columbus, OH
i
AMS Proserv

AMS Proserv

(29)
Certified Public Accounting
“Aaron is professional and friendly, the staff is wonderful too!”
In Business Since 2008
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
3009 Columbus St Suite 103, Grove City, OH 43123
i
Advanced Payroll Solutions

Advanced Payroll Solutions

(3)
“I have been working with this company for several years and they have never let me down.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2010
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Transparent Fees & Pricing
1287 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus, OH
i
Taylor Bookkeeping & Tax Service

Taylor Bookkeeping & Tax Service

(6)
Bookkeeping
“Cheap, professional, easy.”
In Business Since 1969
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Locally Owned & Operated
4143 N High St, Columbus, OH
i
Widetax

Widetax

(19)
  • Questions
“Tatiana Loughman did no hesitate to offer her professional insight and throughout the entire conversation she was sincerely interested to help me and to offer the best advice.”
In Business Since 2020
Transparent Fees & Pricing
341 S 3rd St Suite 100-254, Columbus, OH
i
ABC Accounting and Tax Services

ABC Accounting and Tax Services

(18)
  • Small Business
“ABC Accounting and Tax Service are honest, helpful and professional, and they are an example of the old dictum, go find a professional for your taxes, with Fikru as a licensed CPA, my taxes have been in good hands for over six months.”
In Business Since 2019
Free Initial Consultation
4181 E Main St, Columbus, OH
i
Laubie, Dotson, Ryan

Laubie, Dotson, Ryan

(1)
Industries, Business Services, Tax Services
“They are professional, friendly and have saved me a lot of money since going with them 4 years ago.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2019
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
1041 Dublin Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Trimmer Financial Services

Trimmer Financial Services

(7)
  • Team
“My husband and I were thrilled with our experience with Larry Trimmer.”
In Business Since 2015
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
3030 Wessex Ct, Columbus, OH
i
Simplified Bookkeeping

Simplified Bookkeeping

(3)
  • Company
“Donita & the Simplified Bookkeeping team has been the greatest customer service engagement I have been a part of in quite some time.”
In Business Since 2011
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts Invoicing available
7921 Station St, Columbus, OH
i
Brown Consulting Group

Brown Consulting Group

(2)
“He has taken the time to review forms with us as well as get everything to us in a timely manner.”
In Business Since 2014
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Offers Financing Options
134 Northwoods Blvd 2nd floor, Columbus, OH
i
CPA Advisory Group

CPA Advisory Group

(2)
Quickbooks Services, NIL Financial Literacy, Tax Services
“Friendly and knowledgeable staff, great advice (which we don't always take but should), and comfort in knowing that our taxes will be done professionally every year.”
In Business Since 2002
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
131 Dillmont Dr STE 200, Columbus, OH
i
Count the Penny

Count the Penny

(6)
  • Question
“Has a tendency to gaslight clients, is a little unorganized & tends to blame employees for mistakes (Ex: at times I would get emails about my payment being late, anytime my payment was late it was because I hadn't yet received an invoice from her com...”
In Business Since 2016
Free Initial Consultation
175 S 3rd St #200, Columbus, OH
i
Harper & Company CPA Plus

Harper & Company CPA Plus

(7)
Payroll Services, Quickbooks Training, Business Advisory & Consulting
“Very professional, detailed and an energetic and kind staff that makes you feel welcome.”
In Business Since 2022
Transparent Fees & Pricing
1396 King Ave, Columbus, OH
i
Fifield, Kim & Associates Cpas

Fifield, Kim & Associates Cpas

(5)
“I have been with Jim for over 25 years.”
In Business Since 2010
4930 Reed Rd Suite 100, Columbus, OH 43220
i
Schultz CPA

Schultz CPA

(13)
  • Knowledge
  • Tax Filing
  • Questions
“I have had numerous issues with the IRS for amending previous taxes to claim a homebuyer loan refund and utilizing this company's services has allowed me to recoup $4000 I wouldn't have been able to do on my own.”
In Business Since 2005
1890 Northwest Blvd #240, Columbus, OH
i
SP Payroll and Tax Services

SP Payroll and Tax Services

(2)
“At one point it was over $20,000 and then I got it down to $18,000 but it had been haunting me and I've been paying $600 a month.”
In Business Since 2011
Accepts Paypal
4937 W Broad St, Columbus, OH
i
Wandle & Associates

Wandle & Associates

(2)
“Best accountant we have ever used Positive Quality, Professionalism, Value”
In Business Since 1992
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
25 S Columbus St, Sunbury, OH 43074
i
Capital City Accountants

Capital City Accountants

(1)
“I don't regret switching over to them and highly recommend if you're looking for a professional and easy to work with accountant.”
In Business Since 2014
4937 W Broad St #101, Columbus, OH
i
Frush Consulting

Frush Consulting

“Frush Consulting, LLC was formed in 2019 as the successor firm to Frush & Associates, Inc. Our firm currently employs four accountants, including 3 CPAs. We take pride in our open communication used to reach an understanding of our clients' needs thr...”
In Business Since 1992
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
699 S Front St, Columbus, OH
i
Timberlake & Associates, an M&M Financial Company

Timberlake & Associates, an M&M Financial Company

(3)
Bookkeeping
“Friendly staff, honest, fast, rates are very reasonable.”
In Business Since 1983
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
307 S Hamilton Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Payflex Payroll Services

Payflex Payroll Services

(1)
“I had been using another company for years but, i have not been getting the proper service i need.”
Mettler Toledo, 1900 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH
i

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top