Best Personal Injury Lawyers in Elyria, OH

24 firms listed · 4 in Elyria · 5 open 24/7 · 7 open weekends · 20 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

Michael D. Doyle, Attorney At Law

Michael D. Doyle, Attorney At Law

(37)
  • Case
  • Shark
  • Call
“This men is the truth he is a men of his word he takes your case seriously and he cares I would recommen this layer to anyone I know that needs a layer of the case is up his alley he is the right layer for the job he keep me out of jail and I was abl...”
In Business Since 1997
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
124 Middle Ave #300, Elyria, OH
i
Gemelas, Wilson, Merrill & Fritz Co LPA

Gemelas, Wilson, Merrill & Fritz Co LPA

(32)
  • Results
  • Child
  • Call
“I had probably one of the most difficult eviction cases there is for any landlord, it's also tough to find a eviction attorney that actually cares about the situation your in I got lucky and found that in Michael Wilson, his communication and thoroug...”
In Business Since 2009
Free Initial Consultation
424 Middle Ave, Elyria, OH
i
Brian K. Balser Co. LPA

Brian K. Balser Co. LPA

(4)
“Our case carried on for several years, but he never once wavered or asked for any money out of our pocket.”
In Business Since 2001
Free Initial Consultation
Breakers Blvd Avon, Lake, OH,
i
Baker, Baker & Baker

Baker, Baker & Baker

(7)
“We got the fresh start that we desperately needed and I can't thank Baker, Baker & Baker LLC enough for their excellent, professional legal services!”
In Business Since 2004
Family Business
55 Public Square Ste #1330 409 East Ave., Second Floor, Elyria, OH 44035, Cleveland, OH
i
Stephen P. Hanudel, Attorney at Law

Stephen P. Hanudel, Attorney at Law

(1)
“He took care of my needs for probate Court in a very timely manner”
In Business Since 2012
Free Initial Consultation
124 Middle Ave suite 900, Elyria, OH
i
Smith Geoffrey R

Smith Geoffrey R

(9)
“Very helpful someone was using there property in a scam they got back to me so fast very nice staff.”
In Business Since 2004
124 Middle Ave STE 800, Elyria, OH
i

The 24 firms on this page are the personal injury practices listed for Elyria, OH. What each states about its injury work, consultations and fee arrangements comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Elyria, OH

Of the 24 firms we list here, 4 are in Elyria itself and 20 come from towns including Westlake (4, 11 mi), Rocky River (4, 15 mi) and Lorain (2, 6 mi). The firms on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 425 reviews; 2 have 50 or more reviews and 20 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these firms on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (100%), responsiveness (91%) and quality (80%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "knowledge" and "price". 5 are open around the clock; 7 are open on Saturdays and 6 on Sundays. The practice areas the firms on this page list most often on their websites are wrongful death (5), personal injury (4), criminal defense (3), medical malpractice (3) and amputation (2). 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 15 websites of the firms on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 1 is family- or locally-owned. 1 has Spanish-speaking staff. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book a consultation.

Do the injury firms listed for Elyria publish websites?

All 24 firms on this page link to a website. That is where you can see which injuries the practice takes on, who the attorneys are, and whether the fee arrangement is described anywhere. What a firm leaves off its own site is worth raising on the first call.

The Mellino Law Firm

The Mellino Law Firm

(14)
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Case
“The Mellino Law Firm took the worst thing that ever happened in my life and handled it with such professionalism, care and charisma.”
In Business Since 2004
BBB Rating: A+
Emergency Services
Serving Elyria Area
i
The Law Firm For Truck Safety - Cleveland

The Law Firm For Truck Safety - Cleveland

(19)
  • Knowledge
  • Team
  • Understand
“I have never dealt with attorneys before they were my first and I have to honestly say that it was the best experience I have ever had when I had gotten into my car accident they didn't send me a whole bunch of junk in the mail I was recommended to t...”
In Business Since 2001
Emergency Services
Serving Elyria Area
i
Abogado En Lorain

Abogado En Lorain

(12)
“I recommend attorney Patrick Merrick”
In Business Since 2007
Accepts Cash, Check
Se Habla Español
Emergency Services
947 Broadway Suite 201, Lorain, OH
i
Anthony R. Pecora, Attorney

Anthony R. Pecora, Attorney

(22)
  • Team
  • Children
“We entered his office frightened of what the future may hold for our children as they had been in my husband's custody for years but Pecora quickly eliminated each and every fear we had and went above and beyond what we ever expected of him.”
In Business Since 1973
Serving Elyria Area
i
The Robenalt Law Firm

The Robenalt Law Firm

(13)
  • Justice
  • Case
  • Respect
“It has strong integrity, is responsive and works closely with clients to ensure they are included in the decision making process, minimizing risk, with no upfront costs for the client until a successful result is reached.”
In Business Since 2014
Emergency Services
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Elyria Area
i
Tayeh Law Offices

Tayeh Law Offices

(24)
  • Questions
  • Understanding
“Attorney Reema is very professional knowledgeable and easy to talk to she was extremely quick to respond to all of my questions and concerns during this stressful and emotionally draining time if your looking for a attorney that truly has your best ...”
In Business Since 2017
Serving Elyria Area
i
Trigilio, Stephenson & Dattilo, P.l.l.

Trigilio, Stephenson & Dattilo, P.l.l.

(11)
“This firm resolved an issue I had within days, the attorney assigned to me was josh lamb and he was very friendly and clear with everything.”
In Business Since 2008
5750 Cooper Foster Park Rd Suite 102, Lorain, OH
i
Godinsky Law

Godinsky Law

(21)
  • Job
  • Results
  • Court
“Today me and Chris godinsky from his law firm went to court and let me tell you this man came to battle today with witnesses stacked against us spreading lies just trying to get me charged for something I didn't do to try and save there own self from...”
In Business Since 2012
Emergency Services
Serving Elyria Area
i
The Lancione Law Firm

The Lancione Law Firm

(2)
“Although John was unable to pursue my case, I appreciate how compassionate and humble he was while investigating and speaking to me about the overall situation.”
In Business Since 1963
BBB Rating: A+
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Elyria Area
i
Marsalka Law

Marsalka Law

(7)
  • Felt
“I felt very comfortable during the entire process and at times found myself just venting to him about the cause of needing his services and I am sure he would never admit it, but my rambling probably got annoying, but you would never know.”
In Business Since 2018
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Elyria Area
i
Christine Agnello Russo Law

Christine Agnello Russo Law

(8)
“I was worried about the consequences and she eased my concerns very well and delivered what she said she could do to a tea.”
In Business Since 2020
Serving Elyria Area
i
Lambert Law

Lambert Law

(8)
  • Legal Representation
  • Attorney
  • Divorce
“Professional, knowledgeable, and easy to work with - I can't thank Anita enough for her help during a difficult time for my family and I.”
In Business Since 2023
Serving Elyria Area
i
Colanlaw

Colanlaw

(1)
“Strong lawyer who helped a friend of mine, knowledgeable thorough understand of the process etc.”
In Business Since 2022
Serving Elyria Area
i
Mark E. Barbour, Attorney at Law

Mark E. Barbour, Attorney at Law

(3)
“I appreciated his knowledge of Ohio personal injury law, his experience having dealt with many types of insurance companies, his thorough understanding of the process and the psyche/POV of other lawyers, insurance companies and juries.”
In Business Since 2010
Cash only
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Elyria Area
i
Dodosh LAW Offices

Dodosh LAW Offices

(15)
  • Questions
  • Personal Injury
  • Settlement
“I want to start out in September of 2021 I was hit badly by a intoxicated driver in Macedonia Ohio I had went to a chiropractor in Garfield heights we're at that point my chiropractor had given me some referrals to some lawyers one of them is Nick do...”
In Business Since 2013
Serving Elyria Area
i
Justin D. Gould Law

Justin D. Gould Law

(5)
“After spending a couple of hours gathering information about my car accident, explaining the process, and possible outcomes, we knew we wanted Justin to represent us.”
In Business Since 2022
Serving Elyria Area
i
James B. Kerner Co., Lpa

James B. Kerner Co., Lpa

(9)
  • Price
“His fees are fair, and he goes the extra mile in counseling you on what to do to rebuild your credit after filing.”
In Business Since 2010
Serving Elyria Area
i
McDermott & Hickey

McDermott & Hickey

(4)
“I highly recommend them for anyone searching for the right attorney.”
In Business Since 2013
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Elyria Area
i

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top
Data verified October 16, 2026