View Profile
Vincent Passariello Tax Services
- Communication
“First time using them for my taxes and communication was amazing.”
Best Tax Preparation Services near Middletown, NJ
We have 3 companies in Middletown on file, and all of them are on this list, along with 21 from towns including Staten Island, NY (6, 14 mi), Brooklyn, NY (4, 19 mi) and Morganville (2, 12 mi).
1 open 24/7 · 6 open weekends · 23 rated 4.5+ · 1 shows a license
Data verified October 18, 2026
View Profile
Kelly & Co
View Profile
Schwager Valanzano
View Profile
Chris Whalen, CPA
- Wealth
- Real Estate Investments
“I called Chris fews times about some Questions i had and he answered everytime and i went to his office and he was very helpful and knowledgeable person.”
View Profile
Eco-Tax
- Responsive
- Payroll
- Questions
“In particular, my assigned accountant, Josephine has been professional, patient and thorough in helping me navigate the business side of the tax world.”
View Profile
Boscia Tax Preparer & Accountant
- Small Business
- Emails
- Questions
“Since they had everything in the system from the prior year, it was much easier to update their checklists and see comparisons between both year's data.”
The 24 companies listed for Middletown, NJ prepare and file tax returns for individuals and small businesses. What each says about its services and credentials comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Middletown, NJ
23 of the 24 companies on this page have a rating, from 4.6 to 5.0 across 3,655 reviews; 14 have 50 or more reviews. When clients rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (94%), quality (80%) and responsiveness (79%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication", "patient" and "efficient". 1 is open around the clock; 6 are open on Saturdays and 5 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are tax planning (3), tax preparation (3), bookkeeping (2), business services (2) and incorporation services (2). 1 shows a license on its website and 4 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 17 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 1 offers urgent consultations; 3 offer payment plans and 6 offer a free initial consultation. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.
Why are tax preparers outside Middletown shown on this page?
3 of the 24 companies are located in Middletown. The others come from other towns within 20 mi. Since most returns are handled through a portal, what matters is whether the preparer files in your state. Distances are straight-line.
View Profile
Kreppel Tax Advisory Group
“Elliott Kreppel is a mensch and now his beautiful, well-educated son works with him on all processes as well (it's good to know somebody will be around at the firm for a long time).”
View Profile
Arlia & Associates Cpas
- Saving
- Success
- Questions
“With their great attention to detail and fast, right-on-the-nail response in every step of the way, Loralyn, Paula and the team have been helping me sort out a complex accounting disaster created by another firm.”
View Profile
A&D Tax
- Advice
- Informative
- Team
“Valon Gashi is an experienced knowledgeable professional, not only does he ensure accuracy but also strives to minimize any concerns you may have during busy tax season, by always keeping you informed every step of the way.”
View Profile
Mauriello Enterprises | My Tax Fella
- Season
- Financial
- Team
“He and his team make it easy by setting up a secure portal to supply forms and the turnaround time is always fast and they provide a really helpful report that helps me understand changes from year to year that impact my refund or payment.”
View Profile
A Kaplan CPA
- Tax Preparation
- File
- Questions
“During the consultation, Aleksey took the time to review my existing returns, was able to point where the mishaps happened from the previous CPA, and offered his opinion on how to move forward.”
View Profile
Straight Talk Cpas
- Tax Returns
- Company
- Small Business
“Salim Omar through his book Straight Talk About Small Business Success New Jersey: How to Maximize The Growth, Cash Flow and Profitability Of Your Small Business.”
View Profile
Prosperity Tax Service
- Questions
- Information
“Met with her today and she made the tax filing process easy and painless, and she spotted a deduction I would have missed if I'd attempted to do the filing on my own again (like I did last year) - highly recommend working with Wendy!!”
View Profile
Eclat Financial Consultancy
- Organized
- Confident
- Questions
“I went to a few accountants, it wasn't until I hired Eclat Financial Consultancy to really inspect the business banking records to find out what potential my business really had.”
View Profile
Zippy Tax Service
- Patient
- Check
- Tax Preparer
“Khan and his team was truly a pleasure and will highly recommend them and Zippy Tax Service to friends and colleagues in need of tax services for expatriates.”
View Profile
Goldenthal & Suss Consulting
- Financial Advice
- Small Business
- Questions
“From simple questions to complex issues, Dave and his firm accessible, knowledgeable and clear and direct with their advice; and they are great to work with.”
View Profile
Citywide
- Advices
- Tax Preparer
“Though he did not hire me but gave me some very useful professional advices and because of those advices, today I am a successful tax professional and am managing one of the recently launched pilot tax projects for the small business owners.”
View Profile
Gino Mallamaci, CPA
- Job
- Quality
- Team
“After having some issues with other accounting firms, (errors, lack of follow-up, ridiculously exorbitant fees), it was very important that I find an accountant that was thorough, accurate, good follow-up, and fair fees) for my 8 companies.”
View Profile
CSI Group
- Job
- Taxes
- Accountant
“To be especially knowledgeable, so much so that my wife and I came to him a couple of years ago after going through several Accountants over the years, none of whom fully understood our status (I am retired law enforcement).”
View Profile
Amz Accountant
- System
- Season
- Ecommerce
“We have been working with Gabe since April 2022 we hired him for taxes and he has now become our CPA we are so happy with his hard work & attention to detail!”
View Profile
Gojo Accountants
- Questions
- Communication
- Fee
“They are proactive: I receive advance notice to engage them with their online link to: A simple online questionnaire, prompt to upload relevant forms, review and submit (stressless).”
View Profile
Sidney Finkelstein Pa
“While it would be a stretch to say that my fiance and I look forward to getting our taxes done every year, it's not a stretch to say that Aster brings a little bit of sunshine to an otherwise unpleasant chore”
View Profile
Maria Taber EA
- Questions
- Matter
- Knowledge
“She really took the time to see what was out there that could benefit me most in my situation , and helped enroll me in programs that I didn't even no exist”
View Profile
Unique Financial Advisors & Tax Consultants
- Retirement Planning
- Fiduciary
- Vid
“Vid's sensible advice—understanding markets, growth assets, tax preparation, risk mitigation—has been invaluable in getting me to a far more comfortable spot.”
Tax Preparation & Planning Services in Middletown, NJ Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$273
Maximum cost
$2722
National Average
$490
Avg Per Hour Rates
$260
$327
$708
Fair price range is based on 527 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
