Best Tax Preparation Services near Brookhaven, NY

There are no companies listed in Brookhaven itself yet; the 24 below are the closest options, from towns including Port Jefferson Station (3, 8 mi), Holbrook (2, 7 mi) and Ronkonkoma (2, 9 mi).

9 open weekends · 23 rated 4.5+ · 2 show a license

Data verified October 21, 2026

Notchbooks

Notchbooks

(48)
  • Small Business
  • Understand
  • Knowledge
“Ian has been very helpful with our filings and planning advice, as needed, helping us to understand the implications of tax law on our current and future decisions.”
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2016
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Smithtown, NY · 14 mi from Brookhaven
i
Edwin Casanova, CPA

Edwin Casanova, CPA

(46)
  • Understanding
  • Tax Return
  • Patient
“I have not been the most organized and punctual person to work with through the years but always met with patience and understanding from Edwin and Elise.”
In Business Since 2015
Smithtown, NY · 14 mi from Brookhaven
i
Ross & Company, CPA

Ross & Company, CPA

(50)
  • Responsive
  • Team
  • Tax Returns
“We dedicated countless hours and worked very hard on our store stocking our virtual shelves and shipping thousands of packages to customers across the country.”
In Business Since 2005
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Mount Pleasant, SC · 669 mi from Brookhaven
i
Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service

Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service

(50)
  • Tax Returns
  • Financial
  • Information
“" She can be relied upon to provide accurate information within the confines of tax laws that are in place and constantly informs us of any changes that may help or hurt us in our filings.”
In Business Since 1967
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Kassman Accounting

Kassman Accounting

(49)
  • Tax Return
  • Business Taxes
  • Financial
“I've had a business for 19 years and dealt with other accountants that didn't have the knowledge and understanding of the right things to do for me.”
In Business Since 2010
Coupons & Offers
Central Islip, NY · 13 mi from Brookhaven
i
SMG ABA

SMG ABA

(50)
  • Management
  • Questions
  • Industry
“SMG ABA LLC for a few years now, They have really separated themselves with the level of service and expertise that I haven't found with any other CPA Accounting firm before”
In Business Since 2021
Islandia, NY · 12 mi from Brookhaven
i

The 24 companies listed for Brookhaven, NY prepare and file tax returns for individuals and small businesses. What each says about its services and credentials comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Brookhaven, NY

The 24 companies on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 1,370 reviews; 9 have 50 or more reviews and 23 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these companies on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (96%), responsiveness (75%) and quality (69%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "knowledge", "efficient" and "patient". 9 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are tax services (7), business services (6), quickbooks services (3), payroll services (2) and services for individuals (2). 2 show a license on their websites and 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 14 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 6 offer payment plans; 8 offer a free initial consultation; 1 is family- or locally-owned and 1 lists coupons or special offers. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Are any tax preparers listed for Brookhaven open on Saturdays or Sundays?

9 of the 24 companies list weekend hours. Extended and weekend opening is common through the filing season and disappears afterward, so the hours shown here may not match what you find in the quiet part of the year. Call before you travel.

Saranto Calamas Office

Saranto Calamas Office

(32)
  • Decision
  • Questions
  • Money
“  Starting as a young professional in business through the other accounting needs that come with living a full life - handling of wills, estates and tax planning.”
Free Initial Consultation
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 1999
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Port Jefferson, NY · 10 mi from Brookhaven
i
James Castaldo CPA & Associates

James Castaldo CPA & Associates

(49)
“I've had some severe tax complications, but James, Justin, and the team were able to help me recognize reality and put me at ease with proper tax planning, recommended solutions, and examined the way forward.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2010
Accepts Debit, Check, All Major Credit Cards
Lake Grove, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Tait's Tax Service INC

Tait's Tax Service INC

(34)
  • Accountant
  • File
  • Needs
“He is always up to answering any questions he genuinely cares about his clients experience and goes above and beyond not to mention how speedy the process was, everything was done in a NICK OF TIME :)”
In Business Since 2019
Bay Shore, NY · 17 mi from Brookhaven
i
Michael Verderosa CPA P.C

Michael Verderosa CPA P.C

(32)
  • Patient
  • Needs
  • Advice
“He is more than just a tax guy he understands tax laws and is helping me grow my business he is very helpful and takes time to understand you situation and give you the best advice”
In Business Since 2020
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Mastic Beach, NY · 6 mi from Brookhaven
i
All Island Tax & Accounting

All Island Tax & Accounting

(15)
  • Questions
“Excellent service, highly recommend for personal and business taxes”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2007
BBB Rating: A+
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Thomas Brown CPA

Thomas Brown CPA

(29)
  • Financial
  • Number
“Thomas Brown and his staff are always courteous, knowledgeable, responsive, appropriate, creative, and helpful and all within the parameters of the rules and regulations governing taxation.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2007
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Holbrook, NY · 7 mi from Brookhaven
i
Jones, Little & Co., Cpa's

Jones, Little & Co., Cpa's

(21)
  • Law
  • My Business
  • Consultant
“I highly recommend their services to anyone seeking not only professional expertise but also a level of care and dedication that is hard to find elsewhere.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1999
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Nasir Tax-Care Professional Service

Nasir Tax-Care Professional Service

(50)
  • Price
  • Accountant
“I did my taxes from NASIR TAX-CARE PROFESSIONALS Very Professional and Fast service I really appreciate the time and nature of my job i can't go the the Office location because of my work schedule email all my W-2 and 1099 and it was done same day I ...”
Centereach, NY · 6 mi from Brookhaven
i
Rost & Company, Cpas

Rost & Company, Cpas

(11)
  • Questions
  • Tax Return
  • Team
“Overall, I highly recommend Bobby's team for anyone looking for experienced, reliable, and trustworthy accountants who will get get your tax return finalized quickly with a favorable outcome.”
Free Initial Consultation
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2017
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Ronkonkoma, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Weisman & Co., Cpa's

Weisman & Co., Cpa's

(33)
  • Company
  • Mind
  • Questions
“Lanny, Along with your team of professionals, your skills and talents have kept us on an even keel for 25 years without drastic tax burdens at any one time.”
In Business Since 2005
Licensed
Hauppauge, NY · 12 mi from Brookhaven
i
Twin Forks Tax & Accounting

Twin Forks Tax & Accounting

(14)
“Kevin's Dad did our taxes for years and now Kevin has been doing it for years, we used to dread getting our taxes done before we went to Twin Forks, no more!”
Free Initial Consultation
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2007
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Riverhead, NY · 16 mi from Brookhaven
i
William Carpenter CPA

William Carpenter CPA

(9)
  • Informative
“I have been using him for over 25 years both for my personnel and business needs and I find him honest, hard working and very up on all the new laws and mandates .”
In Business Since 1999
BBB Accredited
Hauppauge, NY · 12 mi from Brookhaven
i
Sebastiano Vitelli & Co Accountants & Consultants

Sebastiano Vitelli & Co Accountants & Consultants

(1)
“Been using him for 30 years and would never go anywhere else.”
In Business Since 2006
BBB Rating: A
Holbrook, NY · 7 mi from Brookhaven
i
Howard S Cohen

Howard S Cohen

(26)
  • File
  • Tax Code
  • Tax Return
“I have had Mr Cohen to do my personal and corporate taxes for over 30 years and I referred many people for his services over the years I highly recommended him”
In Business Since 2008
Licensed
Miller Place, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Long Island Tax Resolution Services

Long Island Tax Resolution Services

(26)
  • Understand
  • Job
  • Result
“He is genuinely concerned about your well being and immediately discusses possible solutions and strategies to put you on a path to decrease your stress, while maximizing your situation to best benefit you.”
In Business Since 2011
Free Initial Consultation
Bohemia, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Rossman Tax Services

Rossman Tax Services

(16)
“Anytime during the year I can call Josh and he always gets back to me as does his staff and they treat their clients not as clients but his family the best in the business.”
Family Business
In Business Since 1999
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Ferrera Destefano & Caporusso Certified Public Accountants

Ferrera Destefano & Caporusso Certified Public Accountants

(1)
“Excellent service from very professional group of accountants and staff.”
Offers Financing Options
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 1993
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Islandia, NY · 12 mi from Brookhaven
i
Peggiann McCoy CPA

Peggiann McCoy CPA

(8)
“Caring Personal /Professional Attention that's what the CPA stands for after her name”
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2007
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Ronkonkoma, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
HomeTax PreparersNew YorkBrookhaven, NY

Tax Preparation & Planning Services in Brookhaven, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$310
Maximum cost
$3099
National Average
$558
Avg Per Hour Rates
$295
$372
$806
Typical price range is based on 347 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $558
Minimum cost $310
Maximum cost $3099
Avg Per Hour Rates $295

Typical range $372 to $806 is based on 347 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

What clients say about companies near Brookhaven

  • “I have a small business and was so worried about tax season but Edwin and his team made taxes and my business needs so effortless and stress free.” — client of Edwin Casanova, CPA
  • “The people at Notchbooks were quick to file my tax return, knowledgeable, thorough and professional throughout the whole process.” — client of Notchbooks
  • “Every time the tax season comes I smile knowing that I will have another successful experience.” — client of Saranto Calamas Office
  • “My tax return was completed within 24 hours of submitting my documents for review.” — client of Edwin Casanova, CPA

Excerpts from public reviews of the companies listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top