Best Tax Preparation Services near Brookhaven, NY

There are no companies listed in Brookhaven itself yet; the 15 below are the closest options, from towns including Port Jefferson Station (4, 8 mi), Patchogue (2, 6 mi) and Holbrook (2, 7 mi).

5 open weekends · 12 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 27, 2026

Saranto

Saranto

4.2 45 reviews
“They take the time to answer questions, listen to concerns and have been a great resource in helping to guide me through financial decisions.”
Free consultationSince 1999FinancingPrices online
Port Jefferson, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Book onlineBook
Michael Verderosa CPA P.C

Michael Verderosa CPA P.C

5.0 75 reviews
“Mike has been doing our taxes for the last 2 years and has done and outstanding job at a very reasonable cost my only regret is that I did not find him sooner”
Serves Mastic Beach, Patchogue +2Since 2020Prices online
Patchogue, NY · 6 mi from Brookhaven
i
Book onlineBook
Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service

Soloway Advisory - Tax Preparation Service

4.9 131 reviews
“I have been working with tax expert Denise Chiarella of Soloway Advisory for more than a decade and I have always been satisfied with the results.”
Free consultation55+ years
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Castaldo CPA

Castaldo CPA

4.8 69 reviews
“I've had some severe tax complications, but James, Justin, and the team were able to help me recognize reality and put me at ease with proper tax planning, recommended solutions, and examined the way forward.”
AICPA memberFree consultationSince 2010
Lake Grove, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
All Island Tax & Accounting

All Island Tax & Accounting

4.4 20 reviews
“Sahra who did my taxes was professional when Taxes were done in a excellent amount of time.”
BBB A+Since 2007
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Nasir Tax-Care Professional Service

Nasir Tax-Care Professional Service

5.0 56 reviews
“Fast, efficient, resourceful, knowledgeable, excellent and all in all the best highly recommended”
6 mi from Brookhaven
i

The 15 companies listed for Brookhaven, NY prepare and file tax returns for individuals and small businesses. What each says about its services and credentials comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Brookhaven, NY

The 15 companies on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 967 reviews; 6 have 50 or more reviews and 12 are rated 4.5 or higher. 5 are open on Saturdays and 2 on Sundays. The services the companies on this page list most often on their websites are business services (4), tax services (4), services for individuals (3) and quickbooks services (2). 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 8 websites of the companies on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 4 offer payment plans; 6 offer a free initial consultation and 1 is family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for 14 of the companies on this page; 11 publish a contact page; 11 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the companies on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the company before you book a consultation.

Are any tax preparers listed for Brookhaven open on Saturdays or Sundays?

5 of the 15 companies list weekend hours. Extended and weekend opening is common through the filing season and disappears afterward, so the hours shown here may not match what you find in the quiet part of the year. Call before you travel.

Thomas Brown CPA

Thomas Brown CPA

5.0 34 reviews
“My family has used Thomas Brown CPA PC for over 20 years and they have always done a wonderful job preparing our taxes.”
Free consultationSince 2007
Holbrook, NY · 7 mi from Brookhaven
i
Jones, Little & Co., Cpa's

Jones, Little & Co., Cpa's

5.0 21 reviews
“I have been their client for over 20 years & they have handled all 3 companies and my personal accounts in a very professional manor.”
Free consultationSince 1999Prices online
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Sebastiano Vitelli & Co Accountants & Consultants

Sebastiano Vitelli & Co Accountants & Consultants

5.0 12 reviews
“Been using him for 30 years and would never go anywhere else.”
BBB ASince 2006
Holbrook, NY · 7 mi from Brookhaven
i
Rost & Company, Cpas

Rost & Company, Cpas

4.3 16 reviews
“Mr Rost goes out of his way to help with all your financial needs.”
Free consultationSince 2017FinancingPrices online
Ronkonkoma, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Long Island Tax Resolution Services

Long Island Tax Resolution Services

5.0 37 reviews
“However, in the end instead of having to pay the IRS Tens of Thousands of Dollars, James was able to prove to the IRS that My filing was correct.”
Free consultationSince 2011
Bohemia, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
O'Hara & Company

O'Hara & Company

5.0 16 reviews
“Mr O'Hara and his employees have been doing our accounting for the past 5 years and they are the best.”
Since 2007FinancingPrices online
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Block Advisors

Block Advisors

4.6 76 reviews
“This was the first time we used Block Advisors to prepare our tax returns, but we will be returning to have our taxes prepared next year.”
Patchogue, NY · 6 mi from Brookhaven
i
Rossman Tax Services

Rossman Tax Services

4.8 17 reviews
“They do an exceptional job and the whole staff is a pleasure to work with.”
Since 1979Family-owned
Port Jefferson Station, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Peggiann McCoy CPA

Peggiann McCoy CPA

4.7 13 reviews
“Outstanding at a great price !!”
Since 2007FinancingPrices online
Ronkonkoma, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
HomeTax PreparersNew YorkBrookhaven, NY

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top