Best Consumer Protection Lawyers in Ithaca, NY

24 firms listed · 12 in Ithaca · 4 open 24/7 · 4 open weekends · 18 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 18, 2026

Luke Z. Fenchel, Attorney-At Law

Luke Z. Fenchel, Attorney-At Law

(49)
  • Misdemeanor
  • Plea
  • Charges
“Unlike some other lawyers who lacked confidence, Luke not only was confident success but also identified loopholes and procedural problems and built a strong case and came down to the best deal possible.”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 2016
200 E Buffalo St #102b, Ithaca, NY
i
Sulimowicz Sharon

Sulimowicz Sharon

(7)
“If anyone in the finger lakes area is in need of a good lawyer , I would recommend Sharon Sulomowicz , very knowledgeable and professional, the best in Ithaca .”
BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 2010
118 N Tioga St #202, Ithaca, NY
i
The Law Office of Charles H. Kee

The Law Office of Charles H. Kee

(22)
  • Understanding
  • Mind
  • Legal Advice
“Through thoughtful action Charles quickly resolved the issue by preparing for the worst, but persuing a path of deescalation for a minor dispute that was dramatically escalated out of control.”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 2018
112 N Cayuga St Suite 2, Ithaca, NY
i
Allen & Maines

Allen & Maines

(1)
“Immensely knowledgeable and helpful staff which made my process easier.”
In Business Since 2018
417 N Cayuga St, Ithaca, NY
i
Thaler & Thaler

Thaler & Thaler

(10)
  • Paralegal
“She kept us posted in the whole process without us constantly checking in, she responded quickly to all the questions we had and she prepared all the documents so well that the closing was smooth.”
In Business Since 1997
309 N Tioga St # 1, Ithaca, NY
i
Prisoners' Legal Services of NY

Prisoners' Legal Services of NY

In Business Since 1999
114 Prospect St #1, Ithaca, NY
i

The 24 firms listed for Ithaca, NY handle consumer disputes for buyers. What each says about faulty goods, credit reporting and collection claims comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Ithaca, NY

Of the 24 firms we list here, 12 are in Ithaca itself and 12 come from towns including Binghamton (7, 39 mi), Cortland (2, 20 mi) and Auburn (1, 34 mi). 23 of the firms on this page have a rating, from 4.0 to 5.0 across 580 reviews; 3 have 50 or more reviews and 18 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these firms on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (100%), responsiveness (88%) and quality (80%). 4 are open around the clock and 4 are open on weekends. The practice areas the firms on this page list most often on their websites are motorcycle accidents (2), personal injury (2), real estate (2), slip and fall injuries (2) and truck accidents (2). 3 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 20 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 45 years. 4 offer urgent consultations and 4 offer a free initial consultation. We have a website on file for all 24 of the firms on this page; 18 publish a contact page and 10 list a public email. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book a consultation.

Do consumer protection firms listed for Ithaca list their claim types?

All 24 firms have a website on file, and most name the consumer claims they take: vehicles, credit reporting, collections, or deceptive sales. That naming is the quickest filter, because a general practice and a dedicated consumer protection firm read very differently on the page.

Salton Peter D Attorney at Law

Salton Peter D Attorney at Law

(4)
“He was very down to earth and seems to know his stuff”
In Business Since 2000
309 N Tioga St, Ithaca, NY
i
Guttman & Reiter

Guttman & Reiter

(4)
“Amazing man and ready to help!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1997
411 N Tioga St, Ithaca, NY
i
Christopher B Colosi Attorney at Law

Christopher B Colosi Attorney at Law

(5)
“Chris, has been a long time legal representative for myself from criminal to traffic and family Court if there ever is a need for any legal advice, Chris is the person I've always thought of first.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2012
308 N Tioga St Suite One, Ithaca, NY
i
Adam Klausner

Adam Klausner

(1)
“He was a great client advocate and even made himself available on off hours to sign documents for my oft-traveling hubby.”
In Business Since 2007
179 Graham Rd, Ithaca, NY
i
The Law Offices of Anna Smith

The Law Offices of Anna Smith

(1)
“Answered all our questions and concerns, available for questions when they came up, price was good, professional in court, paperwork perfect, and no issues.”
In Business Since 2014
104 N Cayuga St Unit 1, Ithaca, NY
i
Lyman & Lyman

Lyman & Lyman

In Business Since 2008
1322 E State St, Ithaca, NY
i
Simonetta & Associates

Simonetta & Associates

Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2002
Cortland, NY · 20 mi from Ithaca
i
Law Office of Keith Dayton

Law Office of Keith Dayton

In Business Since 2008
Cortland, NY · 20 mi from Ithaca
i
Schimmerling Law

Schimmerling Law

(27)
  • Motorcycle
  • Insurance
  • People
“L wasn't able to lift anything so doctor Rob decided that surgery was needed to repair the rotator however he found a slap which wasn't seen on the mri this lead me to feel the need to contact a lawyer.”
Emergency Services
Free Initial Consultation
BBB Rating: A
In Business Since 1982
Binghamton, NY · 39 mi from Ithaca
i
Coughlin & Gerhart

Coughlin & Gerhart

(35)
  • Trial
  • Matter
  • Calls
“My family has worked with three different attorneys and the wonderful assisting staff at Coughlin & Gerhart on three different concerns during the past two years and have received excellent and professional service and support.”
In Business Since 2006
Binghamton, NY · 39 mi from Ithaca
i
Testa Law Firm

Testa Law Firm

(48)
  • Questions
  • Happy
  • Real Estate
“Daniel Testa would personally call with updates, which surpassed my expectations after our experience with the other attorney previously hired in Auburn.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2009
Auburn, NY · 34 mi from Ithaca
i
Scott C. Gottlieb, Injury Law Attorney

Scott C. Gottlieb, Injury Law Attorney

(27)
  • Law Firm
  • Settlement
  • Hands
“Although I asked a lot of questions and may or may not have been directly related to the case, Jan went out of her way to get my questions answered to the best of her abilities.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2004
Binghamton, NY · 39 mi from Ithaca
i
Matthew G. Jubelt Attorney & Counselor at Law

Matthew G. Jubelt Attorney & Counselor at Law

(22)
  • Acquittal
  • Sexual Harassment
  • Doubt
“His prior military service gives him knowledge and experience no other civilian lawyer has, and will benefit any soldier, sailor, airman, or marine in the Watertown area.”
Emergency Services
In Business Since 2021
Cazenovia, NY · 47 mi from Ithaca
i
Crowley and Reynolds

Crowley and Reynolds

(15)
  • Legal Advice
  • Real Estate
“My husband and I would highly recommend Mr Reynolds to anybody that would need their help in this particular situation in anything else that they service.”
In Business Since 2016
Binghamton, NY · 39 mi from Ithaca
i
The Law Office of Theresa M Levine

The Law Office of Theresa M Levine

(14)
“As a single mother who has often felt unheard in the past, she not only strengthened my voice, she provided me the opportunity to finally advocate for my children.”
In Business Since 2020
Binghamton, NY · 39 mi from Ithaca
i
Hogan, Sarzynski, Lynch, Dewind & Gregory

Hogan, Sarzynski, Lynch, Dewind & Gregory

(2)
“They answered all my questions and very clear on the process.”
Remote Consultations Available
BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1981
Johnson City, NY · 35 mi from Ithaca
i
Aswad & Ingraham

Aswad & Ingraham

(13)
“The staff was friendly and courtesy, and knowledgeable in their dealings,”
In Business Since 1997
Binghamton, NY · 39 mi from Ithaca
i
Orville & McDonald Law

Orville & McDonald Law

(2)
“Has been taking care of my legal concerns quickly.”
In Business Since 2014
Binghamton, NY · 39 mi from Ithaca
i

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top