View Profile
Siben & Siben
“When a wrinkle appeared, such as an out of state doctor whose inattention to detail threatened our settlement, we were promptly briefed and the situation resolved in our favor in a short amount of time.”
Best Criminal Defense Lawyers near Bay Shore, NY
1 of these firms is based in Bay Shore; the others serve Bay Shore from towns including Hauppauge (7 mi), Central Islip (3 mi) and Huntington Station (11 mi).
11 open 24/7 · 17 open weekends · 22 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
Mitchell C Elman Law Offices
“Grateful to have met Mitchell Elman , I was hopeless , stressed & he showed me theirs always hope I won my case in less than a year & now I'm a free man .”
View Profile
Roche LAW Group
- Case
- Feel
- Personal Injury
“They've made it a personable and tolerable experience while still maintaining a high level of professionalism and demonstrating tremendous skill along the way.”
View Profile
McGuire, Peláez, Bennett & Belcastro
- Service
- License
- Insurance
“Yeah I'm going to recommend a lawyer for anything, always get a lawyer , this place is awesome no points and just a fine worth the money remember people don't work for free and points or conviction costs way more”
View Profile
Edward Palermo Criminal and DWI Lawyer
- Confidence
- Understanding
- Courthouse
“Face to this very complex cases, Counsellor Ed Palermo brilliantly overcomes to this situation in junction with an immigration lawyer under his supervision to make sure any outcome won't jeopardize our immigration status.”
View Profile
Tucker Lawyers
- Law Firm
- Understanding
- Up to Date
“Completely happy and satisfied with their work with an incredible group of responsible lawyers willing to serve you, they helped me resolve and win the case and made me win a lot of money that I honestly never imagined I would have with me, completel...”
The 24 firms listed for Bay Shore, NY defend criminal charges for people. What each states about the offenses it takes and the courts it appears in comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
The 24 firms on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 2,949 reviews; 17 have 50 or more reviews and 22 are rated 4.5 or higher. When clients rate these firms on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (98%), responsiveness (78%) and quality (68%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the firms on this page are "results", "knowledge" and "understanding". 11 are open around the clock; 17 are open on Saturdays and 15 on Sundays. The practice areas the firms on this page list most often on their websites are criminal defense (7), criminal law (6), car accidents (4), motorcycle accidents (3) and traffic (3). 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. 18 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 29 years. 12 offer urgent consultations; 16 offer a free initial consultation; 1 is family- or locally-owned and 1 lists coupons or special offers. 4 have Spanish-speaking staff. We have a website on file for 23 of the firms on this page; 21 publish a contact page; 15 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the firms on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the firm before you book a consultation.
Do any criminal law firms listed for Bay Shore offer free consultations?
16 of the 24 criminal defense firms here state that a first consultation carries no charge. Treat it as a chance to ask how your kind of charge is handled and who would cover your hearings. It is not the moment to describe the facts in detail to several firms in a row.
View Profile
Castro & Trodden
- Case
- Reduce
- Prosecutor
“I am very pleased to have Attorney Bryan Trodden work on my cases at the Suffolk County Traffic and Parking Violations Agency since it was getting very complicated for me to do anything on my own and even was having a hard time finding a law office f...”
View Profile
Law Offices of John Caffrey
- License
- Phone
- Felt
“John is one of the best lawyers I ever felt with he is very up front and honest about how it's gunna go and what he can get the tickets to he was able to help me out on all 5 of my tickets his communication through the process was amazing and the pr...”
View Profile
Badanes Law Office
- Phone Calls
- Responsive
- Esq
“It was the toughest 3 1/2 years of my life; and with a child involved, we were able to secure a good final stipulation, win sole custody, secure child support, as well as marital property,, QDRO, and all documents necessary to rest all cases in our d...”
View Profile
Lori Cabrera, Attorney at Law
- Communication
- Driving
- Points
“Her dedication to achieving a favorable outcome was evident throughout the entire process, and I am impressed by her ability to navigate the complexities of traffic law with ease.”
View Profile
Mitev Law Firm
- Expertise
- Call
- Aggressive
“A straight shooter from the very beginning, he proved to be forthright with all aspects of my case and moved straight ahead with the next step in the proceedings with efficiency and ease, making everything a seamless process.”
View Profile
Laurence A. Silverman & Associates
- Court
- Life
- Driving
“Andrew is the best lawyer we hired to look after our family member and he let us know through out the process everything will be fine and it surely was.”
View Profile
Matthew Tuohy Esquire
- Court
- Jail
- Money
“Sometime doesn't get to explain everything before court but when it comes down to it he is very very fair with pricing so I'm sure his case load is huge and at the end of the day it's the result and he comes through every time.”
View Profile
Jacoby & Jacoby
“And all staff of the Medford Jacoby&Jacoby office are exemplary; when referring those I know to the firm, I do so knowing excellent service is provided.”
View Profile
Mandler & Sieger
- Service
- Questions
- The Office
“I highly recommend Mandler & Sieger ,LLP because they represented me on my case and they did a great job 😀😀 I'm very happy thanks guys 👍👍 …”
View Profile
Law Offices Of Jonathan B. Manley
- Call
- Legal Services
- Traffic Tickets
“Jon was knowledgable of the law, and explained my options in easy to understand terms, I could not be happier with the result, and would recommend him without hesitation.”
View Profile
Law Office of Shawn R. Kassman
- Traffic
- Prices
- Court
“This law office is outstanding Shawn will have your best interest at heart and will do everything in his power to resolve the situation or problem that your in ....”
View Profile
The Law Offices of Cory H. Morris
- Results
- Legal Advice
- Court
“I got let go from my job my ex company denied my unemployment benefits made a call to Cory did everything he wanted me to filed an appeal and Cory won the case I have severe sleep apnea and was late to work due to it a few times but that's besides th...”
View Profile
Riegler & Berkowitz
“We had our offer accepted at the beginning of the pandemic and his knowledge and expertise helped us feel confident in moving forward knowing that if anything happened he would protect our interests.”
View Profile
The Latronica Law Firm
- Calls
“My case was very long (due to Covid) and when I would call even during the pandemic, I would always speak to Louis or an associate and they were still working tirelessly on my case.”
View Profile
Law Office of Glenn Kurtzrock
- Court
- License
- Fee
“He was spot on with his time line of the process and how it would turn out - If I ever needed a question answered - it didn't not matter what time of the day I asked - he answered in a timely fashion I could not have been happier with the choice I m...”
View Profile
The Matera Law Firm
- Team
- Compassion
- Courtroom
“If you are the victim of an accident, Michael Matera is there for all of your legal needs and will do what ever is possible to get what is fair and due to you.”
View Profile
Law Offices of Michael J. Alber
- Team
- Divorce
- Passion
“He is able to think on his feet and quickly synthesize information to make compelling arguments with little lead time – which evidences both his deep understanding of the relevant facts and relevant law.”
View Profile
Cozzolaw
- Life Saver
- Driving
- Communication
“We hired joe to try to tackle some driving while suspended misdemeanors as well as 2 warrants and about 12 other tickets in Nassau and Suffolk that were very old.”
Criminal Law Attorney Services in Bay Shore, NY Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$1500
Maximum cost
$18000
National Average
$5500
Avg Per Hour Rates
$350
$3500
$6000
Average price range is based on 535 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
